Champions

SEASON CHAMPION(S)
1964 Alfred
1965 Alfred & St. Lawrence
1966 Alfred
1967 Alfred
1968 Union
1969 St. Lawrence
1970 Alfred
1971 Alfred
1972 Alfred
1973 Hobart
1974 Ithaca
1975 Ithaca
1976 Alfred
1977 Ithaca
1978 Ithaca
1979 Ithaca
1980 Ithaca
1981 Alfred
1982 St. Lawrence
1983 St. Lawrence
1984 Ithaca
1985 Ithaca
1986 Ithaca
1987 Ithaca
1988 Ithaca & RPI
1989 Alfred
1990 Ithaca & RPI

Ineligible for Championship

The ICAC had a rule that a team had to play at least half the other teams in the conference in order to be eligible for the championship. When the number of football teams expanded to six in 1972, that rule required a minimum of three games for each team. The following teams were ineligible for the championship.

SEASON TEAMS INELIGIBLE
1972 Ithaca and RIT each played only two games. Ithaca was undefeated (2-0) but not named co- champions with undefeated Alfred (3-0).
1973 Ithaca played only two games. Ithaca was undefeated (2-0) but not named champion, the championship instead went to Hobart (3-1-1).