Champions

# -- Indicates participation later vacated due to NCAA infractions.

SEASON CHAMPION
1973 Wittenberg
1974 Central
1975 Wittenberg
1976 St. John's
1977 Widener
1978 Baldwin Wallace
1979 Ithaca
1980 Dayton
1981 Widener
1982 West Georgia
1983 Augustana
1984 Augustana
1985 Augustana
1986 Augustana
1987 Wagner
1988 Ithaca
1989 Dayton
1990 Allegheny
1991 Ithaca
1992 Wisconsin-La Crosse
1993 Mount Union
1994 Albion
1995 Wisconsin-La Crosse
1996 Mount Union
1997 Mount Union
1998 Mount Union
1999 Pacific Lutheran
2000 Mount Union
2001 Mount Union
2002 Mount Union
2003 St. John's
2004 Linfield
2005 Mount Union
2006 Mount Union
2007 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2008 Mount Union
2009 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2010 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2011 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2012 Mount Union
2013 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2014 Wisconsin-Whitewater
2015 Mount Union
2016 #Mary Hardin-Baylor
2017 Mount Union
2018 Mary Hardin-Baylor
2019 North Central