NOTE:
- A hash (#) indicates participation later vacated due to NCAA infractions.
JUMP TO:
- 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979
- 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989
- 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999
- 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
- 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
- 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
1973
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Juniata 35, Bridgeport 14 | Bridgeport |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Wittenberg 21, San Diego 14 | Springfield |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Wittenberg 41, Juniata 0 | Phenix City |
1974
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Central 17, Evansville 16 | Evansville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Ithaca 27, Slippery Rock 14 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Central 10, Ithaca 8 | Phenix City |
1975
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Ithaca 41, Fort Valley State 12 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Millsaps 28, Colorado College 21 | Colorado Springs |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Widener 14, Albright 6 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wittenberg 17, Indiana Central 13 | Springfield |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Ithaca 23, Widener 14 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wittenberg 55, Millsaps 22 | Springfield |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wittenberg 28, Ithaca 0 | Phenix City |
1976
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Buena Vista 20, Carroll 14 (ot) | Waukesha |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. John's 46, Augustana 7 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. Lawrence 26, Albright 7 | Canton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Towson State 14, C.W. Post 10 | Brookville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | St. John's 61, Buena Vista 0 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Towson State 38, St. Lawrence 36 | Towson |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | St. John's 31, Towson State 28 | Phenix City |
1977
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Albany 51, Hampden-Sydney 45 | Hampden-Sydney |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Minnesota-Morris 13, Albion 10 | Morris |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wabash 20, St. John's 9 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Widener 19, Central 0 | Pella |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wabash 37, Minnesota-Morris 21 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Widener 33, Albany 15 | Chester |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Widener 39, Wabash 36 | Phenix City |
1978
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Baldwin Wallace 71, St. Lawrence 7 | Berea |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Carnegie Mellon 24, Dayton 21 | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Minnesota-Morris 23, St. Olaf 10 | Morris |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wittenberg 6, Ithaca 3 | Ithaca |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Baldwin Wallace 31, Carnegie Mellon 6 | Berea |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wittenberg 35, Minnesota-Morris 14 | Springfield |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Baldwin Wallace 24, Wittenberg 10 | Phenix City |
1979
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Carnegie Mellon 31, Minnesota-Morris 25 (ot) | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Ithaca 27, Dubuque 7 | Dubuque |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Widener 29, Baldwin Wallace 8 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wittenberg 21, Millersville 14 | Millersville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Ithaca 15, Carnegie Mellon 6 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wittenberg 17, Widener 14 | Springfield |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Ithaca 14, Wittenberg 10 | Phenix City |
1980
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Dayton 34, Baldwin Wallace 0 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Ithaca 41, Wagner 13 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Minnesota-Morris 41, Dubuque 35 | Morris |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Widener 43, Bethany 12 | Bethany |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Dayton 28, Widener 24 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Ithaca 36, Minnesota-Morris 0 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Dayton 63, Ithaca 0 | Phenix City |
1981
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Dayton 19, Augustana 7 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Lawrence 21, Minnesota-Morris 14 (ot) | Appleton |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Montclair State 13, Alfred 12 | Alfred |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Widener 10, West Georgia 3 | Carrollton |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Dayton 38, Lawrence 0 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Widener 23, Montclair State 12 | Chester |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Widener 17, Dayton 10 | Phenix City |
1982
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Augustana 28, Baldwin Wallace 22 | Berea |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Bishop 32, Wartburg 7 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. Lawrence 43, Wagner 34 | Staten Island |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | West Georgia 31, Widener 24 (ot) | Carrollton |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Augustana 14, St. Lawrence 0 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | West Georgia 27, Bishop 6 | Carrollton |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | West Georgia 14, Augustana 0 | Phenix City |
1983
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Augustana 22, Adrian 21 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Salisbury 16, Carnegie Mellon 14 | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Union 51, Hofstra 19 | Hempstead |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 43, Occidental 42 | Los Angeles |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Augustana 21, Wisconsin-La Crosse 15 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Union 23, Salisbury 21 | Salisbury |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Augustana 21, Union 17 | Kings Mills |
1984
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Augustana 14, Dayton 13 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Central 23, Occidental 22 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Union 26, Plymouth State 14 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Washington and Jefferson 22, Randolph-Macon 21 | Ashland |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Augustana 23, Union 6 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Central 20, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Pella |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Augustana 21, Central 12 | Kings Mills |
1985
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Augustana 26, Albion 10 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Central 27, Coe 7 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Gettysburg 14, Lycoming 10 | Gettysburg |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Ithaca 13, Union 12 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Montclair State 28, Western Connecticut 0 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mount Union 35, Denison 3 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Occidental 28, St. John's 10 | Los Angeles |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Salisbury 35, Carnegie Mellon 22 | Salisbury |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Augustana 21, Mount Union 14 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Central 71, Occidental 0 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Gettysburg 22, Salisbury 6 | Gettysburg |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Ithaca 50, Montclair State 28 | Ithaca |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Augustana 14, Central 7 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Ithaca 34, Gettysburg 0 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Augustana 20, Ithaca 7 | Phenix City |
1986
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Augustana 34, Hope 10 | Holland |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Central 37, Buena Vista 0 | Storm Lake |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Concordia-Moorhead 24, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 15 | Moorhead |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Ithaca 24, Union 17 (ot) | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Montclair State 24, Hofstra 21 | Hempstead |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mount Union 42, Dayton 36 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Salisbury 34, Emory and Henry 20 | Bristol |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Susquehanna 28, Washington and Jefferson 20 | Washington |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Augustana 16, Mount Union 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Concordia-Moorhead 17, Central 14 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Ithaca 29, Montclair State 15 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Salisbury 31, Susquehanna 17 | Selinsgrove |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Augustana 41, Concordia-Moorhead 7 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Salisbury 44, Ithaca 40 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Augustana 31, Salisbury 3 | Phenix City |
1987
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Augustana 53, Hiram 0 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Central 17, Menlo 0 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Dayton 52, Capital 28 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Emory and Henry 49, Ferrum 7 | Roanoke |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Fordham 41, Hofstra 6 | Hempstead |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | St. John's 7, Gustavus Adolphus 3 | St. Peter |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wagner 38, Rochester 14 | Staten Island |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Washington and Jefferson 23, Allegheny 17 (ot) | Meadville |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Central 13, St. John's 3 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Dayton 38, Augustana 36 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Emory and Henry 23, Washington and Jefferson 16 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wagner 21, Fordham 0 | Bronx |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Dayton 34, Central 0 | Dayton |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Wagner 20, Emory and Henry 15 | Emory |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Wagner 19, Dayton 3 | Phenix City |
1988
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Augustana 25, Adrian 7 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Central 7, Concordia-Moorhead 0 | Moorhead |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Cortland 32, Hofstra 27 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Ferrum 34, Rhodes 10 | Rocky Mount |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Ithaca 34, Wagner 31 (ot) | Staten Island |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Moravian 17, Widener 7 | Bethlehem |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 29, Simpson 27 | Indianola |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wittenberg 35, Dayton 28 (ot) | Dayton |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Augustana 28, Wittenberg 14 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Central 16, Wisconsin-Whitewater 13 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Ferrum 49, Moravian 28 | Rocky Mount |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Ithaca 24, Cortland 17 | Ithaca |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Central 23, Augustana 17 (ot) | Pella |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Ithaca 62, Ferrum 28 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Ithaca 39, Central 24 | Phenix City |
1989
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Central 55, St. Norbert 7 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Dayton 35, John Carroll 10 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Ferrum 41, Washington and Jefferson 7 | Rocky Mount |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Lycoming 21, Dickinson 0 | Carlisle |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Millikin 21, Augustana 12 | Decatur |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Montclair State 23, Hofstra 6 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | St. John's 42, Simpson 35 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Union 42, Cortland 14 | Schenectady |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Dayton 28, Millikin 16 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Ferrum 49, Lycoming 24 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | St. John's 27, Central 24 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Union 45, Montclair State 6 | Schenectady |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Dayton 28, St. John's 0 | Dayton |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Union 37, Ferrum 21 | Rocky Mount |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Dayton 17, Union 7 | Phenix City |
1990
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Allegheny 26, Mount Union 15 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Central 24, Redlands 14 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Dayton 24, Augustana 14 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Hofstra 35, Cortland 9 | Hempstead |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Lycoming 17, Carnegie Mellon 7 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. Thomas 24, Wisconsin-Whitewater 23 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Trenton State 24, Ithaca 14 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Washington and Jefferson 10, Ferrum 7 | Washington |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Allegheny 31, Dayton 23 | Meadville |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Central 33, St. Thomas 32 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Hofstra 38, Trenton State 3 | Ewing |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Lycoming 24, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Washington |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Allegheny 24, Central 7 | Pella |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Lycoming 20, Hofstra 10 | Hempstead |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Allegheny 21, Lycoming 14 (ot) | Bradenton |
1991
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Allegheny 24, Albion 21 (ot) | Meadville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Dayton 27, Baldwin Wallace 10 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Ithaca 31, Glassboro State 10 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Lycoming 18, Washington and Jefferson 16 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | St. John's 75, Coe 2 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Susquehanna 21, Dickinson 20 | Carlisle |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Union 55, Massachusetts-Lowell 16 | Schenectady |
| Sun., Nov. 24 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 28, Simpson 13 | Cedar Falls |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Dayton 28, Allegheny 25 (ot) | Meadville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Ithaca 35, Union 23 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | St. John's 29, Wisconsin-La Crosse 10 | Minneapolis |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Susquehanna 31, Lycoming 24 | Selinsgrove |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Dayton 19, St. John's 7 | Dayton |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Ithaca 49, Susquehanna 13 | Selinsgrove |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Ithaca 34, Dayton 20 | Bradenton |
1992
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Buffalo State 28, Ithaca 26 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Central 20, Carleton 8 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Emory and Henry 17, Thomas More 0 | Emory |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Illinois Wesleyan 21, Aurora 12 | Bloomington |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mount Union 27, Dayton 10 | Dayton |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Rowan 41, WPI 14 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Washington and Jefferson 33, Lycoming 0 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 47, Redlands 26 | La Crosse |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Mount Union 49, Illinois Wesleyan 27 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Rowan 28, Buffalo State 19 | Buffalo |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Washington and Jefferson 51, Emory and Henry 15 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 34, Central 9 | Ames |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Washington and Jefferson 18, Rowan 13 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 29, Mount Union 24 | La Crosse |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 16, Washington and Jefferson 12 | Bradenton |
1993
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Albion 41, Anderson 21 | Albion |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Frostburg State 26, Wilkes 25 | Wilkes-Barre |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mount Union 40, Allegheny 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Rowan 29, Buffalo State 6 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. John's 32, Coe 14 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Washington and Jefferson 27, Moravian 7 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | William Paterson 17, Union 7 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 55, Wartburg 26 | La Crosse |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mount Union 30, Albion 16 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Rowan 37, William Paterson 0 | Wayne |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | St. John's 47, Wisconsin-La Crosse 25 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Washington and Jefferson 28, Frostburg State 7 | Frostburg |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mount Union 56, St. John's 8 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Rowan 23, Washington and Jefferson 16 | Washington |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Mount Union 34, Rowan 24 | Salem |
1994
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Albion 28, Augustana 21 | Albion |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Ithaca 10, Buffalo State 7 (ot) | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mount Union 28, Allegheny 19 | Meadville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Plymouth State 19, Merchant Marine 18 | Plymouth |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. John's 51, La Verne 12 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wartburg 22, Central 21 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Washington and Jefferson 28, Trinity (TX) 0 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Widener 14, Dickinson 0 | Carlisle |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Albion 34, Mount Union 33 | Albion |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Ithaca 22, Plymouth State 7 | Plymouth |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | St. John's 42, Wartburg 14 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Washington and Jefferson 37, Widener 21 | Washington |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Albion 19, St. John's 16 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Washington and Jefferson 23, Ithaca 19 | Ithaca |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Albion 38, Washington and Jefferson 15 | Salem |
1995
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Lycoming 31, Widener 27 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Mount Union 52, Hanover 18 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Rowan 46, Buffalo State 7 | Buffalo |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Union 24, Plymouth State 7 | Plymouth |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Washington and Jefferson 35, Emory and Henry 16 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wheaton 63, Wittenberg 41 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 45, Concordia-Moorhead 7 | Fargo |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-River Falls 10, Central 7 | Pella |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Mount Union 40, Wheaton 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Rowan 38, Union 7 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Washington and Jefferson 48, Lycoming 0 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 28, Wisconsin-River Falls 14 | La Crosse |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Rowan 28, Washington and Jefferson 15 | Washington |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 20, Mount Union 17 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 36, Rowan 7 | Salem |
1996
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| Regionals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Albright 31, Washington and Jefferson 17 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | College of New Jersey 17, Coast Guard 16 | Ewing |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Illinois Wesleyan 23, Albion 20 | Albion |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Lycoming 31, Ursinus 24 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mount Union 31, Allegheny 26 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Rowan 21, Buffalo State 20 | Buffalo |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | St. John's 21, Simpson 18 | Minneapolis |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 44, Wisconsin-River Falls 0 | La Crosse |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Lycoming 31, Albright 13 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mount Union 49, Illinois Wesleyan 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Rowan 7, College of New Jersey 3 | Ewing |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 37, St. John's 30 | La Crosse |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mount Union 39, Wisconsin-La Crosse 21 | Madison |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Rowan 33, Lycoming 14 | Glassboro |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Mount Union 56, Rowan 24 | Salem |
1997
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Augsburg 34, Concordia-Moorhead 22 | Fargo |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | College of New Jersey 34, Cortland 30 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | John Carroll 30, Hanover 20 | Hanover |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Lycoming 27, Western Maryland 13 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mount Union 34, Allegheny 30 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Rowan 43, Coast Guard 0 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Simpson 34, Wisconsin-Whitewater 31 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Trinity (TX) 44, Catholic 33 | San Antonio |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Lycoming 46, Trinity (TX) 26 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mount Union 59, John Carroll 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Rowan 13, College of New Jersey 7 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Simpson 61, Augsburg 21 | Indianola |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Lycoming 28, Rowan 20 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Mount Union 54, Simpson 7 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Mount Union 61, Lycoming 12 | Salem |
1998
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Buffalo State 38, Springfield 35 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Lycoming 49, Catholic 14 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mount Union 21, Albion 19 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Rowan 26, College of New Jersey 2 | Ewing |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | St. John's 33, Pacific Lutheran 20 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Trinity (TX) 30, Western Maryland 20 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 28, Central 21 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wittenberg 13, Millikin 10 | Springfield |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Mount Union 21, Wittenberg 19 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Rowan 19, Buffalo State 17 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Trinity (TX) 37, Lycoming 21 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 10, St. John's 7 | Collegeville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Mount Union 34, Trinity (TX) 29 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Rowan 22, Wisconsin-Eau Claire 19 | Glassboro |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Mount Union 44, Rowan 24 | Salem |
1999
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Augustana 39, St. Norbert 32 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Central 38, Wisconsin-La Crosse 17 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Hardin-Simmons 28, Washington 21 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Montclair State 37, Buffalo State 34 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Ohio Northern 56, Hanover 14 | Hanover |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Pacific Lutheran 28, Willamette 24 | Salem |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Rowan 29, RPI 10 | Troy |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. John's 23, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 10 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Ursinus 43, Bridgewater State 38 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Washington and Jefferson 14, Lycoming 7 | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Western Maryland 20, Catholic 16 | Westminster |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wittenberg 42, Alma 19 | Springfield |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Hardin-Simmons 51, Washington and Jefferson 3 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Montclair State 32, Western Connecticut 24 | Danbury |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mount Union 42, Augustana 33 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Ohio Northern 58, Wittenberg 24 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Pacific Lutheran 49, Wartburg 14 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Rowan 55, Ursinus 0 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | St. John's 10, Central 9 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Trinity (TX) 20, Western Maryland 16 | San Antonio |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mount Union 56, Ohio Northern 31 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Pacific Lutheran 19, St. John's 9 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Rowan 42, Montclair State 13 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Trinity (TX) 40, Hardin-Simmons 33 | San Antonio |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Pacific Lutheran 49, Trinity (TX) 28 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Rowan 24, Mount Union 17 (ot) | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 18 | Pacific Lutheran 42, Rowan 13 | Salem |
2000
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Bridgewater 59, Washington and Jefferson 42 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Central 29, St. Norbert 14 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Hanover 20, Hope 3 | Holland |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Hobart 25, Bridgewater State 0 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Ohio Northern 47, Millikin 21 | Ada |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Pacific Lutheran 41, Bethel 13 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Springfield 31, Montclair State 29 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | St. John's 26, Wisconsin-Stout 19 | Menomonie |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Trinity (TX) 21, Wesley 3 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Western Maryland 38, Emory and Henry 14 | Emory |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Widener 33, Union 26 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wittenberg 31, Aurora 20 | Springfield |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Central 20, Linfield 17 (ot) | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Hardin-Simmons 32, Western Maryland 10 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Mount Union 59, Ohio Northern 28 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Springfield 13, Brockport 6 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | St. John's 28, Pacific Lutheran 21 (ot) | Tacoma |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Trinity (TX) 47, Bridgewater 41 (ot) | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Widener 40, Hobart 14 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wittenberg 32, Hanover 21 | Springfield |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Hardin-Simmons 33, Trinity (TX) 30 | Abilene |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Mount Union 32, Wittenberg 15 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | St. John's 21, Central 18 | Pella |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Widener 61, Springfield 27 | Springfield |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Mount Union 70, Widener 30 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 9 | St. John's 38, Hardin-Simmons 14 | Abilene |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 16 | Mount Union 10, St. John's 7 | Salem |
2001
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Augustana 54, Defiance 14 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Ithaca 35, Montclair State 23 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Pacific Lutheran 27, Whitworth 26 (ot) | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Rowan 40, Brockport 17 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. John's 27, St. Norbert 20 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Thomas More 34, MacMurray 30 | Crestview Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Trinity (TX) 30, Mary Hardin-Baylor 6 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Washington and Jefferson 24, Western Maryland 21 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Western Connecticut 8, Westfield State 7 | Westfield |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Widener 56, Christopher Newport 7 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point 37, Bethel 27 | Stevens Point |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wittenberg 38, Hardin-Simmons 35 (ot) | Abilene |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Bridgewater 41, Trinity (TX) 37 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Ithaca 27, RPI 10 | Troy |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mount Union 32, Augustana 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Pacific Lutheran 27, Central 21 (ot) | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Rowan 43, Western Connecticut 14 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | St. John's 9, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 7 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Widener 46, Washington and Jefferson 30 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wittenberg 41, Thomas More 0 | Crestview Hills |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Bridgewater 57, Widener 32 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mount Union 49, Wittenberg 21 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Rowan 48, Ithaca 0 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | St. John's 31, Pacific Lutheran 6 | Fargo |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Bridgewater 29, Rowan 24 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Mount Union 35, St. John's 14 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 15 | Mount Union 30, Bridgewater 27 | Salem |
2002
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Brockport 16, Springfield 0 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Coe 21, Wisconsin-La Crosse 18 | Cedar Rapids |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | John Carroll 27, Hobart 7 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | King's 28, Salisbury 0 | Wilkes-Barre |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Muhlenberg 56, Massachusetts-Dartmouth 6 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | St. John's 31, Redlands 24 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Trinity (TX) 48, Mary Hardin-Baylor 38 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wabash 42, MacMurray 7 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wartburg 45, Lake Forest 0 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Washington and Jefferson 24, Christopher Newport 10 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wheaton 42, Alma 14 | Alma |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wittenberg 34, Hanover 33 | Hanover |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Bridgewater 19, King's 17 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Brockport 15, Rowan 12 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | John Carroll 21, Muhlenberg 10 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Linfield 52, Wartburg 15 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mount Union 42, Wheaton 21 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | St. John's 45, Coe 14 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Trinity (TX) 45, Washington and Jefferson 10 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wabash 25, Wittenberg 14 | Crawfordsville |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | John Carroll 16, Brockport 10 (ot) | Rochester |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mount Union 45, Wabash 16 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | St. John's 21, Linfield 14 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Trinity (TX) 38, Bridgewater 32 | Bridgewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Mount Union 57, John Carroll 19 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Trinity (TX) 41, St. John's 34 | San Antonio |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 21 | Mount Union 48, Trinity (TX) 7 | Salem |
2003
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Baldwin Wallace 54, Hanover 32 | Berea |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Bridgewater 28, Waynesburg 24 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Christopher Newport 24, Muhlenberg 20 | Newport News |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | East Texas Baptist 42, Trinity (TX) 41 (ot) | Marshall |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Ithaca 14, Brockport 9 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Linfield 31, Redlands 23 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Montclair State 20, Allegheny 19 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | RPI 34, Curry 20 | Troy |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | St. Norbert 26, Simpson 20 (ot) | De Pere |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wartburg 21, Bethel 7 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wheaton 55, Hope 45 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 52, Concordia (WI) 13 | La Crosse |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Bridgewater 26, Christopher Newport 3 | Newport News |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Ithaca 33, Montclair State 13 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Linfield 23, Wartburg 20 | Salem |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Lycoming 13, East Texas Baptist 7 (ot) | Williamsport |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mount Union 39, Wisconsin-La Crosse 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | RPI 40, Springfield 34 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | St. John's 38, St. Norbert 13 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wheaton 16, Baldwin Wallace 12 | Wheaton |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Mount Union 56, Wheaton 10 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | RPI 21, Ithaca 16 | Troy |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | St. John's 31, Linfield 25 | Collegeville |
| Sun., Dec. 7 | Bridgewater 13, Lycoming 9 | Williamsport |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Mount Union 66, Bridgewater 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | St. John's 38, RPI 10 | Collegeville |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 20 | St. John's 24, Mount Union 6 | Salem |
2004
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Carthage 31, Alma 28 | Alma |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Christopher Newport 35, Salisbury 24 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Concordia-Moorhead 28, Wartburg 14 | Moorhead |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Delaware Valley 21, Shenandoah 17 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Hobart 35, Curry 16 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 32, Trinity (TX) 13 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Occidental 28, Willamette 14 | Los Angeles |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. John Fisher 31, Muhlenberg 3 | Pittsford |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Washington and Jefferson 55, Bridgewater 48 (ot) | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wheaton 31, Mount St. Joseph 7 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 37, St. Norbert 23 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wooster 41, Aurora 34 | Wooster |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Carthage 14, Wooster 7 | Wooster |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Delaware Valley 26, St. John Fisher 20 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Linfield 52, Wisconsin-La Crosse 14 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, Hardin-Simmons 28 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mount Union 27, Wheaton 6 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Occidental 42, Concordia-Moorhead 40 | Fargo |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Rowan 45, Hobart 14 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Washington and Jefferson 24, Christopher Newport 14 | Washington |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Linfield 56, Occidental 27 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 52, Washington and Jefferson 16 | Washington |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mount Union 38, Carthage 20 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Rowan 56, Delaware Valley 7 | Glassboro |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Linfield 52, Rowan 0 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 38, Mount Union 35 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 18 | Linfield 28, Mary Hardin-Baylor 21 | Salem |
2005
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Augustana 49, Lakeland 22 | Rock Island |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Bridgewater 30, Washington and Jefferson 21 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Capital 21, North Central 19 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Concordia-Moorhead 27, Coe 14 | Moorhead |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Delaware Valley 37, Curry 22 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Hobart 23, Cortland 22 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Linfield 63, Occidental 21 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 35, Trinity (TX) 6 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mount Union 49, Mount St. Joseph 6 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Rowan 42, Wilkes 3 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. John's 62, Monmouth 3 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Thiel 28, Johns Hopkins 3 | Greenville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Union 55, Ithaca 41 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wabash 38, Albion 20 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wesley 59, Ferrum 14 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 34, Central 14 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Bridgewater 24, Thiel 13 | Greenville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Capital 14, Wabash 11 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Delaware Valley 21, Hobart 14 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Linfield 28, Concordia-Moorhead 14 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mount Union 44, Augustana 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Rowan 28, Union 24 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wesley 46, Mary Hardin-Baylor 36 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 34, St. John's 7 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Mount Union 34, Capital 31 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Rowan 27, Delaware Valley 21 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wesley 46, Bridgewater 7 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 44, Linfield 41 | McMinnville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Mount Union 19, Rowan 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 58, Wesley 6 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 17 | Mount Union 35, Wisconsin-Whitewater 28 | Salem |
2006
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Capital 32, Wittenberg 14 | Bexley |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Carnegie Mellon 21, Millsaps 0 | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 33, Hardin-Simmons 21 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Mount Union 49, Hope 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | North Central 35, Concordia (WI) 6 | Milwaukee |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Rowan 20, #Hobart 18 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Springfield 42, Curry 14 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | St. John Fisher 49, Union 21 | Pittsford |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | St. John's 21, Central 13 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Washington and Jefferson 27, Christopher Newport 23 | Newport News |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wesley 49, Dickinson 21 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wheaton 42, Mount St. Joseph 28 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Whitworth 27, Occidental 23 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wilkes 42, Washington and Lee 0 | Wilkes-Barre |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 28, Bethel 21 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 59, St. Norbert 17 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Capital 41, North Central 13 | Bexley |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 30, Washington and Jefferson 27 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Mount Union 35, Wheaton 3 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Rowan 21, Wilkes 14 | Wilkes-Barre |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | St. John Fisher 27, Springfield 21 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | St. John's 21, Whitworth 3 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wesley 37, Carnegie Mellon 0 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 24, Wisconsin-La Crosse 21 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Mount Union 17, Capital 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | St. John Fisher 31, Rowan 0 | Pittsford |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Wesley 34, Mary Hardin-Baylor 20 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 17, St. John's 14 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Mount Union 26, St. John Fisher 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 44, Wesley 7 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 16 | Mount Union 35, Wisconsin-Whitewater 16 | Salem |
2007
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Bethel 28, Concordia (WI) 0 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Case Western Reserve 21, Widener 20 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Central 38, Olivet 17 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | College of New Jersey 17, RPI 14 | Troy |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Curry 42, Hartwick 21 | Milton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 52, Trinity (TX) 23 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mount Union 42, Ithaca 18 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Muhlenberg 31, Salisbury 21 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | North Carolina Wesleyan 35, Washington and Jefferson 34 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | North Central 44, Franklin 42 | Franklin |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. John Fisher 24, #Hobart 7 | Pittsford |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. John's 41, Redlands 13 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wabash 31, Mount St. Joseph 21 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wesley 45, Hampden-Sydney 17 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 24, St. Norbert 20 | De Pere |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 34, Capital 14 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Bethel 21, Wisconsin-Eau Claire 12 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Central 37, St. John's 7 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 64, North Carolina Wesleyan 0 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mount Union 59, College of New Jersey 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | St. John Fisher 38, Curry 7 | Pittsford |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wabash 38, Case Western Reserve 23 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wesley 38, Muhlenberg 21 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 59, North Central 28 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Bethel 27, Central 7 | Pella |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 27, Wesley 10 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mount Union 52, St. John Fisher 10 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 47, Wabash 7 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Mount Union 62, Bethel 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 16, Mary Hardin-Baylor 7 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 15 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Mount Union 21 | Salem |
2008
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Cortland 31, Plymouth State 14 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Curry 26, Ithaca 21 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Franklin 62, Otterbein 45 | Westerville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Hobart 33, Lycoming 15 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 38, Hardin-Simmons 35 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Millsaps 51, LaGrange 26 | Jackson |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Monmouth 42, Aurora 13 | Monmouth |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mount Union 56, Randolph-Macon 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | North Central 44, Thomas More 23 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wabash 20, Case Western Reserve 17 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wartburg 26, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 21 | Stevens Point |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Washington and Jefferson 35, Christopher Newport 29 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wesley 20, Muhlenberg 0 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wheaton 14, Trine 0 | Angola |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Willamette 48, Occidental 33 | Salem |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 37, St. John's 7 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Cortland 42, Curry 0 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Franklin 38, North Central 28 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 46, Wesley 14 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mount Union 42, Hobart 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wartburg 30, Monmouth 28 | Monmouth |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Washington and Jefferson 35, Millsaps 20 | Jackson |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wheaton 59, Wabash 28 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 30, Willamette 27 | Salem |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 63, Washington and Jefferson 7 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Mount Union 41, Cortland 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wheaton 45, Franklin 28 | Franklin |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 34, Wartburg 17 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Mount Union 45, Wheaton 24 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 39, Mary Hardin-Baylor 13 | Belton |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 20 | Mount Union 31, Wisconsin-Whitewater 26 | Salem |
2009
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Albright 35, Alfred 25 | Alfred |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Coe 34, St. John's 27 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Delaware Valley 66, Susquehanna 7 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Illinois Wesleyan 41, Wabash 35 (ot) | Bloomington |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Johns Hopkins 23, Hampden-Sydney 7 | Hampden-Sydney |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Linfield 38, California Lutheran 17 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, Central 40 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mississippi College 56, Huntingdon 35 | Montgomery |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Montclair State 38, Maine Maritime 22 | Upper Montclair |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mount Union 55, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | St. Thomas 43, Monmouth 21 | Monmouth |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Thomas More 49, DePauw 39 | Crestview Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Trine 51, Case Western Reserve 38 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wesley 55, North Carolina Wesleyan 23 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 70, Lakeland 7 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wittenberg 42, Mount St. Joseph 14 | Springfield |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Albright 27, Delaware Valley 3 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Johns Hopkins 31, Thomas More 29 | Crestview Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Linfield 53, Mary Hardin-Baylor 21 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Mount Union 62, Montclair State 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | St. Thomas 34, Coe 7 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wesley 43, Mississippi College 9 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, Illinois Wesleyan 7 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wittenberg 34, Trine 17 | Springfield |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Linfield 31, St. Thomas 20 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Mount Union 55, Albright 3 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Wesley 12, Johns Hopkins 0 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Wittenberg 13 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Mount Union 24, Wesley 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 27, Linfield 17 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 38, Mount Union 28 | Salem |
2010
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Alfred 60, Maritime College 0 | Alfred |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Bethel 28, Wartburg 20 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Cortland 49, Endicott 35 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Delaware Valley 23, Salisbury 12 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Linfield 42, California Lutheran 26 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 59, Christopher Newport 7 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Montclair State 16, Hampden-Sydney 14 | Hampden-Sydney |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mount Union 49, St. Lawrence 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | North Central 57, St. Norbert 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Ohio Northern 37, Wittenberg 14 | Ada |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. Thomas 57, Benedictine 10 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Thomas More 42, Washington and Lee 14 | Crestview Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Trine 45, DePauw 35 | Greencastle |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wesley 53, Muhlenberg 14 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wheaton 31, Coe 21 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 52, Franklin 21 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Alfred 34, Cortland 20 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Bethel 15, Wheaton 10 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 69, Thomas More 7 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mount Union 31, Delaware Valley 3 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | North Central 28, Ohio Northern 9 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | St. Thomas 24, Linfield 17 (ot) | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Wesley 44, Montclair State 7 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, Trine 31 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Bethel 12, St. Thomas 7 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mount Union 37, Alfred 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Wesley 19, Mary Hardin-Baylor 9 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 20, North Central 10 | Naperville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Mount Union 34, Bethel 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 27, Wesley 7 | Dover |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sat., Dec. 18 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Mount Union 21 | Salem |
2011
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Centre 51, Hampden-Sydney 41 | Danville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Delaware Valley 62, Norwich 10 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Franklin 24, Thomas More 21 | Franklin |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Kean 34, Christopher Newport 10 | Union |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Linfield 30, California Lutheran 27 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 34, Redlands 13 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | McMurry 25, Trinity (TX) 16 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Monmouth 33, Illinois Wesleyan 27 (ot) | Bloomington |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mount Union 47, Benedictine 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | North Central 59, Dubuque 13 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Salisbury 62, Western New England 24 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. John Fisher 23, Johns Hopkins 12 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. Thomas 48, St. Scholastica 2 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wabash 38, Illinois College 20 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wesley 35, Hobart 28 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 59, Albion 0 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 49, McMurry 20 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mount Union 30, Centre 10 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Salisbury 49, Kean 47 (ot) | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | St. John Fisher 27, Delaware Valley 14 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | St. Thomas 38, Monmouth 10 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wabash 29, North Central 28 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wesley 49, Linfield 34 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 41, Franklin 14 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Mount Union 20, Wabash 8 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | St. Thomas 45, St. John Fisher 10 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wesley 27, Mary Hardin-Baylor 24 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 34, Salisbury 14 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Mount Union 28, Wesley 21 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 20, St. Thomas 0 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 16 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 13, Mount Union 10 | Salem |
2012
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Bethel 24, Concordia-Chicago 23 | River Forest |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Cortland 20, Framingham State 19 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Elmhurst 27, Coe 24 | Cedar Rapids |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Franklin 42, Adrian 10 | Adrian |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Hobart 38, Washington and Lee 20 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Johns Hopkins 42, Washington and Jefferson 10 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Linfield 27, Pacific Lutheran 24 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 59, Louisiana College 20 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mount Union 72, Christopher Newport 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | North Central 41, California Lutheran 21 | Thousand Oaks |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Salisbury 17, Rowan 9 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. Thomas 48, St. Norbert 17 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wesley 73, Mount Ida 14 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Widener 44, Bridgewater State 14 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 55, St. Scholastica 10 | Oshkosh |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wittenberg 52, Heidelberg 38 | Tiffin |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Hobart 35, Wittenberg 10 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Linfield 30, North Central 14 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 63, Franklin 17 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mount Union 55, Johns Hopkins 13 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | St. Thomas 24, Elmhurst 17 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wesley 56, Cortland 6 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Widener 28, Salisbury 7 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 37, Bethel 14 | Oshkosh |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 32, Wesley 20 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mount Union 72, Widener 17 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | St. Thomas 47, Hobart 7 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 31, Linfield 24 (ot) | McMinnville |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Mount Union 48, Mary Hardin-Baylor 35 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 8 | St. Thomas 28, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 14 | St. Paul |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 14 | Mount Union 28, St. Thomas 10 | Salem |
2013
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Bethel 70, St. Scholastica 13 | Minneapolis |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Franklin 17, Washington 10 | Franklin |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Hampden-Sydney 42, Maryville 34 | Hampden-Sydney |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Hobart 34, Gallaudet 7 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Ithaca 20, Framingham State 17 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Linfield 42, Pacific Lutheran 21 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 35, Redlands 7 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mount Union 34, Washington and Jefferson 20 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | North Central 63, Albion 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Rowan 24, Endicott 0 | Glassboro |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | St. John Fisher 25, John Carroll 16 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wartburg 41, Illinois Wesleyan 7 | Bloomington |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wesley 29, Johns Hopkins 24 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wisconsin-Platteville 54, Concordia (WI) 20 | Platteville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, St. Norbert 7 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wittenberg 59, Lebanon Valley 17 | Springfield |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Bethel 34, Wartburg 27 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Linfield 31, Hampden-Sydney 21 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 59, Rowan 8 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mount Union 56, Wittenberg 21 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | North Central 52, Wisconsin-Platteville 24 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | St. John Fisher 27, Hobart 6 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wesley 23, Ithaca 15 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 33, Franklin 3 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 45, St. John Fisher 23 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mount Union 62, Wesley 59 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | North Central 41, Bethel 17 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 28, Linfield 17 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Mount Union 41, North Central 40 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 16, Mary Hardin-Baylor 15 | Belton |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 20 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 52, Mount Union 14 | Salem |
2014
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Christopher Newport 29, Delaware Valley 26 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Hobart 22, Ithaca 15 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | John Carroll 63, Centre 28 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Johns Hopkins 24, Rowan 16 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Linfield 55, Chapman 24 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 27, Texas Lutheran 20 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | MIT 27, Husson 20 (ot) | Bangor |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Mount Union 63, Adrian 3 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | St. John's 35, St. Scholastica 7 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wabash 33, Franklin 14 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wartburg 37, St. Thomas 31 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Washington and Jefferson 41, Wittenberg 25 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wesley 52, Hampden-Sydney 7 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wheaton 43, Benedictine 14 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Widener 36, Muhlenberg 35 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 55, Macalester 2 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Hobart 24, Johns Hopkins 21 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | John Carroll 14, Wheaton 12 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Linfield 31, Mary Hardin-Baylor 28 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mount Union 67, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wartburg 21, St. John's 10 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wesley 59, MIT 0 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Widener 37, Christopher Newport 27 | Chester |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 38, Wabash 14 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Linfield 45, Widener 7 | Chester |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Mount Union 36, John Carroll 28 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wesley 41, Hobart 13 | Dover |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 37, Wartburg 33 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Mount Union 70, Wesley 21 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 20, Linfield 14 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 43, Mount Union 34 | Salem |
2015
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Albright 49, Norwich 0 | Reading |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Cortland 45, Salisbury 21 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Huntingdon 38, Hendrix 27 | Montgomery |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Johns Hopkins 52, Western New England 20 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Linfield 48, Whitworth 10 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 37, Hardin-Simmons 19 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Mount Union 55, St. Lawrence 23 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Ohio Northern 27, Franklin 22 | Franklin |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | St. John's 51, Dubuque 7 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | St. Thomas 57, La Verne 14 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Thomas More 51, Washington and Lee 21 | Crestview Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wabash 35, Albion 14 | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wesley 42, Framingham State 22 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wheaton 55, Lakeland 6 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 48, St. Scholastica 0 | Oshkosh |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 48, St. Norbert 0 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Linfield 38, Cortland 22 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 43, Huntingdon 23 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Mount Union 66, Albright 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | St. Thomas 38, St. John's 19 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wabash 33, Thomas More 27 (ot) | Crawfordsville |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wesley 42, Johns Hopkins 37 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 42, Ohio Northern 7 | Oshkosh |
| Sat., Nov. 28 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Wheaton 17 | Wheaton |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Linfield 38, Mary Hardin-Baylor 35 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Mount Union 56, Wesley 35 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | St. Thomas 38, Wabash 7 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 29 | Oshkosh |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Mount Union 36, Wisconsin-Whitewater 6 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 12 | St. Thomas 38, Linfield 17 | St. Paul |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 18 | Mount Union 49, St. Thomas 35 | Salem |
2016
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 50, Redlands 28 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Alfred 33, Bridgewater State 27 (ot) | Alfred |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Coe 21, Monmouth 14 | Cedar Rapids |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | John Carroll 37, Olivet 12 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Johns Hopkins 42, Randolph-Macon 21 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Linfield 24, Hardin-Simmons 10 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mount Union 38, Hobart 21 | Geneva |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | North Central 41, Rose-Hulman 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. John's 32, Wisconsin-Platteville 31 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. Thomas 43, Northwestern (MN) 0 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wesley 38, Stevenson 17 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Western New England 44, Husson 27 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wheaton 45, Huntingdon 10 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 49, Washington 13 | Oshkosh |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, Lakeland 27 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wittenberg 33, Thomas More 30 (ot) | Crestview Hills |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 27, Linfield 10 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Alfred 30, Western New England 24 | Alfred |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | John Carroll 20, Wesley 17 (ot) | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mount Union 28, Johns Hopkins 21 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | St. Thomas 55, Coe 6 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wheaton 31, North Central 14 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 31, St. John's 14 | Oshkosh |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 37, Wittenberg 9 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 38, Wheaton 16 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | John Carroll 31, Wisconsin-Whitewater 14 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Mount Union 70, Alfred 45 | Alfred |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 34, St. Thomas 31 | St. Paul |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 14, Mount Union 12 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 10, John Carroll 3 | Oshkosh |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 16 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 10, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 7 | Salem |
2017
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 50, Chapman 6 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Berry 34, Huntingdon 20 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Brockport 66, Plymouth State 0 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Case Western Reserve 28, Illinois Wesleyan 0 | Bloomington |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Delaware Valley 35, Western New England 0 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Frostburg State 35, Wittenberg 7 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Husson 23, Springfield 21 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Linfield 27, Hardin-Simmons 13 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Mount Union 21, Washington and Lee 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | North Central 17, St. John's 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | St. Thomas 47, Eureka 8 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Trine 63, Monmouth 24 | Angola |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wartburg 35, Franklin 34 (ot) | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Washington and Jefferson 31, Johns Hopkins 28 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wesley 45, RPI 27 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 63, Lakeland 0 | Oshkosh |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Linfield 0 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Brockport 49, Wesley 28 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Delaware Valley 37, Husson 15 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Frostburg State 46, Washington and Jefferson 23 | Washington |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Mount Union 45, Case Western Reserve 16 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | St. Thomas 29, Berry 13 | St. Paul |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wartburg 49, Trine 7 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 42, North Central 21 | Oshkosh |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, St. Thomas 10 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Brockport 31, Delaware Valley 28 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Mount Union 70, Frostburg State 37 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 41, Wartburg 27 | Oshkosh |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Brockport 0 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Mount Union 43, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 40 | Oshkosh |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 15 | Mount Union 12, #Mary Hardin-Baylor 0 | Salem |
2018
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Berry 31, Maryville 0 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Bethel 41, Wartburg 14 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Brockport 40, Framingham State 27 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Centre 54, Washington and Jefferson 13 | Danville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Frostburg State 42, Western New England 24 | Frostburg |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Johns Hopkins 49, MIT 0 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 27, Hardin-Simmons 6 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Mount Union 60, Denison 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Muhlenberg 20, Delaware Valley 13 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | North Central 52, Hanover 0 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Randolph-Macon 23, John Carroll 20 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | RPI 38, Husson 14 | Troy |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. John's 84, Martin Luther 6 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | St. Norbert 31, Trine 7 | Angola |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Whitworth 48, Claremont-Mudd-Scripps 6 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 17 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 67, Eureka 14 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Bethel 27, North Central 24 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Johns Hopkins 58, Frostburg State 27 | Frostburg |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 75, Berry 9 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Mount Union 51, Centre 35 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Muhlenberg 35, Randolph-Macon 6 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | RPI 21, Brockport 13 | Brockport |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | St. John's 45, Whitworth 24 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 24 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 54, St. Norbert 21 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Johns Hopkins 37, RPI 14 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 21, St. John's 18 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Mount Union 38, Muhlenberg 10 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 1 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 26, Bethel 12 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 31, Wisconsin-Whitewater 14 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 8 | Mount Union 28, Johns Hopkins 20 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 14 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Mount Union 16 | Shenandoah |
2019
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Brockport 33, Western New England 28 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Central 38, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 37 (ot) | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Chapman 68, Linfield 65 (ot) | Orange |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Delaware Valley 30, Bridgewater 22 | Bridgewater |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Huntingdon 27, Berry 24 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 43, Redlands 14 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mount Union 65, Hanover 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Muhlenberg 38, MIT 0 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | North Central 51, Wabash 15 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Salisbury 83, Maritime College 0 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | St. John's 51, Aurora 47 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Union 24, Case Western Reserve 21 | Schenectady |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wartburg 41, Hope 3 | Holland |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wesley 58, Framingham State 21 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wheaton 51, Martin Luther 7 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 35, Monmouth 10 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Delaware Valley 45, Wesley 10 | Dover |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, Huntingdon 6 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Muhlenberg 42, Brockport 0 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | North Central 59, Mount Union 52 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Salisbury 62, Union 41 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | St. John's 55, Chapman 26 | Orange |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wheaton 49, Central 13 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 41, Wartburg 28 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Muhlenberg 24, Salisbury 8 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | North Central 31, Delaware Valley 14 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | St. John's 34, Wheaton 33 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 26, Mary Hardin-Baylor 7 | Belton |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | North Central 45, Muhlenberg 14 | Allentown |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 35, St. John's 32 | Whitewater |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 20 | North Central 41, Wisconsin-Whitewater 14 | Shenandoah |
2021
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Birmingham-Southern 24, Huntingdon 14 | Birmingham |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Central 61, Bethel 35 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Cortland 26, Springfield 21 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Delaware Valley 62, Anna Maria 10 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | DePauw 26, Rose-Hulman 21 | Greencastle |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Johns Hopkins 45, Salisbury 20 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Linfield 44, Redlands 10 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 13, Trinity (TX) 3 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Mount Union 52, Washington and Lee 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Muhlenberg 45, Framingham State 0 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | RPI 20, Endicott 14 | Beverly |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | St. John's 41, Lake Forest 14 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wheaton 63, Aurora 31 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 58, Albion 23 | Albion |
| Sat., Nov. 20 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 69, Greenville 7 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Central 30, Wheaton 28 | Pella |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Linfield 31, St. John's 28 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, Birmingham-Southern 7 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Mount Union 45, Johns Hopkins 35 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Muhlenberg 14, Delaware Valley 0 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | North Central 34, Wisconsin-La Crosse 20 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | RPI 21, Cortland 14 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 27 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, DePauw 0 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 49, Linfield 24 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Mount Union 35, Muhlenberg 29 (ot) | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | North Central 55, RPI 6 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 4 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 51, Central 21 | Whitewater |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 11 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Wisconsin-Whitewater 7 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Dec. 11 | North Central 26, Mount Union 13 | Alliance |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 17 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 57, North Central 24 | Canton |
2022
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Alma 41, Mount St. Joseph 21 | Alma |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Aurora 33, Wisconsin-Whitewater 28 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Bethel 34, Wheaton 32 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Carnegie Mellon 45, DePauw 14 | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Delaware Valley 59, Gallaudet 0 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Ithaca 63, Massachusetts-Dartmouth 20 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Linfield 51, Pomona-Pitzer 24 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 54, Huntingdon 0 | Belton |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Mount Union 51, Salisbury 0 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | North Central 50, Lake Forest 0 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Randolph-Macon 35, Cortland 28 | Ashland |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Springfield 17, Endicott 14 | Beverly |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | St. John's 49, Northwestern (MN) 0 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Trinity (TX) 14, Hardin-Simmons 7 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Utica 17, Susquehanna 10 | Selinsgrove |
| Sat., Nov. 19 | Wartburg 14, Wisconsin-La Crosse 6 | Waverly |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Aurora 48, Alma 26 | Alma |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Bethel 30, Linfield 13 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Delaware Valley 39, Randolph-Macon 32 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Ithaca 31, Springfield 20 | Ithaca |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Trinity (TX) 17 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Mount Union 45, Utica 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | North Central 28, Carnegie Mellon 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 26 | Wartburg 23, St. John's 20 | Collegeville |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 41, Bethel 28 | Belton |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Mount Union 22, Delaware Valley 6 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | North Central 48, Ithaca 7 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 3 | Wartburg 45, Aurora 17 | Waverly |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 10 | Mount Union 34, Wartburg 31 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 10 | North Central 49, Mary Hardin-Baylor 14 | Naperville |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 16 | North Central 28, Mount Union 21 | Annapolis |
2023
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Alma 32, DePauw 17 | Alma |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Aurora 20, Coe 7 | Aurora |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Cortland 23, Endicott 17 | Beverly |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Grove City 21, Susquehanna 20 | Selinsgrove |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Ithaca 21, Springfield 7 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Johns Hopkins 62, Western Connecticut 20 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Mount Union 56, Alfred State 14 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | North Central 65, Belhaven 0 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Randolph-Macon 28, Christopher Newport 20 | Ashland |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Trinity (TX) 20, Hardin-Simmons 6 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Union 24, Delaware Valley 16 | Doylestown |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wartburg 49, Illinois College 14 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wheaton 41, Mount St. Joseph 34 | Wheaton |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Whitworth 42, Chapman 28 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 62, Minnesota-Morris 7 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 18 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 42, Bethel 14 | Whitewater |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Alma 24, Mount Union 20 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Cortland 25, Grove City 24 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Johns Hopkins 39, Union 17 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | North Central 71, Trinity (TX) 28 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Randolph-Macon 46, Ithaca 0 | Ashland |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wartburg 42, Whitworth 20 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 56, Aurora 35 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Nov. 25 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 49, Wheaton 42 | Whitewater |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Cortland 58, Alma 41 | Alma |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | North Central 55, Wisconsin-La Crosse 42 | La Crosse |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Randolph-Macon 39, Johns Hopkins 36 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Dec. 2 | Wartburg 31, Wisconsin-Whitewater 28 | Waverly |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 9 | Cortland 49, Randolph-Macon 14 | Ashland |
| Sat., Dec. 9 | North Central 34, Wartburg 27 | Waverly |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Fri., Dec. 15 | Cortland 38, North Central 37 | Salem |
2024
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Bethel 31, Coe 26 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Endicott 44, Alfred State 0 | Beverly |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | John Carroll 52, Mount St. Joseph 7 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | King's 32, Ursinus 29 | Wilkes-Barre |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 29, Trinity (TX) 22 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Maryville 20, Berry 16 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Whitworth 21, Pomona-Pitzer 13 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 23 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 59, Northwestern (MN) 14 | La Crosse |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Bethel 48, Lake Forest 21 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Carnegie Mellon 24, Centre 15 | Pittsburgh |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Cortland 17, Endicott 9 | Cortland |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | DePauw 45, Maryville 20 | Greencastle |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Hope 49, Aurora 21 | Holland |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Johns Hopkins 17, Grove City 14 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Linfield 65, Texas Lutheran 3 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 17, Hardin-Simmons 13 | Abilene |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Mount Union 42, John Carroll 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | North Central 42, Whitworth 17 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Randolph-Macon 38, Washington and Jefferson 22 | Ashland |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Salisbury 33, King's 13 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Springfield 54, Massachusetts-Dartmouth 27 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | St. John's 24, Wisconsin-La Crosse 13 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Susquehanna 42, Hobart 35 | Selinsgrove |
| Sat., Nov. 30 | Wartburg 19, Wisconsin-Platteville 14 | Waverly |
| Third Round | ||
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Bethel 24, Wartburg 14 | Waverly |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Johns Hopkins 14, DePauw 9 | Greencastle |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 28, Linfield 18 | McMinnville |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Mount Union 24, Carnegie Mellon 19 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | North Central 41, Hope 21 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Salisbury 35, Randolph-Macon 14 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Springfield 40, Cortland 28 | Cortland |
| Sat., Dec. 7 | Susquehanna 41, St. John's 38 | Collegeville |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Johns Hopkins 17, Mary Hardin-Baylor 10 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Mount Union 38, Salisbury 17 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | North Central 27, Springfield 3 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 14 | Susquehanna 24, Bethel 21 | Selinsgrove |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 21 | Mount Union 45, Johns Hopkins 37 | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 21 | North Central 66, Susquehanna 0 | Naperville |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sun., Jan. 5 | North Central 41, Mount Union 25 | Houston |
2025
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION |
|---|---|---|
| First Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Chapman 18, Whitworth 16 | Spokane |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Coe 44, Concordia (WI) 7 | Mequon |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Hanover 23, Grove City 15 | Hanover |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | LaGrange 24, Framingham State 21 | Framingham |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Muhlenberg 34, Union 26 | Allentown |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Springfield 21, Cortland 7 | Springfield |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Susquehanna 38, Washington and Jefferson 32 | Selinsgrove |
| Sat., Nov. 22 | Wheaton 76, Crown 14 | Wheaton |
| Second Round | ||
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Berry 18, LaGrange 14 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Bethel 51, Coe 26 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | DePauw 26, Wisconsin-Whitewater 23 | Whitewater |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Eastern 28, Franklin and Marshall 24 | Lancaster |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | John Carroll 35, Randolph-Macon 6 | Cleveland |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Johns Hopkins 34, Springfield 14 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Mount Union 49, Muhlenberg 7 | Alliance |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | North Central 38, Hanover 6 | Naperville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Salisbury 35, Endicott 28 | Salisbury |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | St. John's 49, Monmouth 15 | Collegeville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Susquehanna 42, Christopher Newport 28 | Newport News |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Trinity (TX) 34, Hardin-Simmons 24 | San Antonio |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wheaton 28, Wartburg 24 | Waverly |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 9, Hope 7 | Holland |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wisconsin-Platteville 24, Alma 7 | Platteville |
| Sat., Nov. 29 | Wisconsin-River Falls 58, Chapman 7 | River Falls |
| Third Round | ||
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Berry 31, Trinity (TX) 23 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Bethel 35, Wisconsin-Platteville 24 | Arden Hills |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | John Carroll 10, Mount Union 7 (ot) | Alliance |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Johns Hopkins 45, Salisbury 13 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | North Central 35, Wisconsin-La Crosse 27 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Susquehanna 29, Eastern 0 | St. Davids |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wheaton 49, DePauw 24 | Greencastle |
| Sat., Dec. 6 | Wisconsin-River Falls 42, St. John's 14 | River Falls |
| Quarterfinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 13 | John Carroll 21, Berry 13 | Mount Berry |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Johns Hopkins 40, Susquehanna 10 | Baltimore |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | North Central 35, Bethel 21 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 13 | Wisconsin-River Falls 46, Wheaton 21 | River Falls |
| Semifinals | ||
| Sat., Dec. 20 | North Central 41, John Carroll 21 | Naperville |
| Sat., Dec. 20 | Wisconsin-River Falls 48, Johns Hopkins 41 | River Falls |
| Stagg Bowl | ||
| Sun., Jan. 4 | Wisconsin-River Falls 24, North Central 14 | Canton |