NOTE:
- A hash (#) indicates participation later vacated due to NCAA infractions.
JUMP TO:
- Adrian Albany Albion Albright Alfred Alfred State Allegheny Alma Anderson Anna Maria Augsburg Augustana Aurora
- Baldwin Wallace Belhaven Benedictine Berry Bethany Bethel Birmingham-Southern Bishop Bridgeport Bridgewater Bridgewater State Brockport Buena Vista Buffalo State
- C.W. Post California Lutheran Capital Carleton Carnegie Mellon Carroll Carthage Case Western Reserve Catholic Central Centre Chapman Christopher Newport Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Coast Guard Coe Colorado College Concordia (WI) Concordia-Chicago Concordia-Moorhead Cortland Crown Curry
- Dayton Defiance Delaware Valley Denison DePauw Dickinson Dubuque
- East Texas Baptist Eastern Elmhurst Emory and Henry Endicott Eureka Evansville
- Ferrum Fordham Fort Valley State Framingham State Franklin Franklin and Marshall Frostburg State
- Gallaudet Gettysburg Greenville Grove City Gustavus Adolphus
- Hampden-Sydney Hanover Hardin-Simmons Hartwick Heidelberg Hendrix Hiram Hobart Hofstra Hope Huntingdon Husson
- Illinois College Illinois Wesleyan Indianapolis Ithaca
- John Carroll Johns Hopkins Juniata
- Kean King's
- La Verne LaGrange Lake Forest Lakeland Lawrence Lebanon Valley Linfield Louisiana College Lycoming
- Macalester MacMurray Maine Maritime Maritime College Martin Luther Mary Hardin-Baylor Maryville MIT Massachusetts-Dartmouth Massachusetts-Lowell McDaniel McMurry Menlo Merchant Marine Millersville Millikin Millsaps Minnesota-Morris Mississippi College Monmouth Montclair State Moravian Mount Ida Mount St. Joseph Mount Union Muhlenberg
- College of New Jersey North Carolina Wesleyan North Central Northwestern (MN) Norwich
- Occidental Ohio Northern Olivet Otterbein
- Pacific Lutheran Plymouth State Pomona-Pitzer
- Randolph-Macon Redlands RPI Rhodes Rochester Rose-Hulman Rowan
- St. John Fisher St. John's St. Lawrence St. Norbert St. Olaf St. Scholastica St. Thomas Salisbury San Diego Shenandoah Simpson Slippery Rock Springfield Stevenson Susquehanna
- Texas Lutheran Thiel Thomas More Towson Trine Trinity (TX)
- Union Ursinus Utica
- Wabash Wagner Wartburg Washington Washington and Jefferson Washington and Lee Waynesburg Wesley West Georgia Western Connecticut Western New England Westfield State Wheaton Whitworth Widener Wilkes Willamette William Paterson Wisconsin-Eau Claire Wisconsin-La Crosse Wisconsin-Oshkosh Wisconsin-Platteville Wisconsin-River Falls Wisconsin-Stevens Point Wisconsin-Stout Wisconsin-Whitewater Wittenberg Wooster WPI
Adrian
Albany
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Hampden-Sydney | W 51-45 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1977 | Widener | L 15-33 | Chester | Semifinal |
Albion
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Minnesota-Morris | L 10-13 | Morris | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Augustana | L 10-26 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Allegheny | L 21-24 (ot) | Meadville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Anderson | W 41-21 | Albion | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Mount Union | L 16-30 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Augustana | W 28-21 | Albion | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Mount Union | W 34-33 | Albion | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1994 | St. John's | W 19-16 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 1994 | Washington and Jefferson | W 38-15 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Illinois Wesleyan | L 20-23 | Albion | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Mount Union | L 19-21 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Wabash | L 20-38 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 0-59 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | North Central | L 7-63 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wabash | L 14-35 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 23-58 | Albion | First Round |
Albright
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Widener | L 6-14 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | St. Lawrence | L 7-26 | Canton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Washington and Jefferson | W 31-17 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Lycoming | L 13-31 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Alfred | W 35-25 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Delaware Valley | W 27-3 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Mount Union | L 3-55 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Norwich | W 49-0 | Reading | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Mount Union | L 7-66 | Alliance | Second Round |
Alfred
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Montclair State | L 12-13 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Albright | L 25-35 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Maritime College | W 60-0 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Cortland | W 34-20 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Mount Union | L 7-37 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Bridgewater State | W 33-27 (ot) | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Western New England | W 30-24 | Alfred | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Mount Union | L 45-70 | Alfred | Quarterfinal |
Alfred State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Mount Union | L 14-56 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Endicott | L 0-44 | Beverly | First Round |
Allegheny
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Washington and Jefferson | L 17-23 (ot) | Meadville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Mount Union | W 26-15 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Dayton | W 31-23 | Meadville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1990 | Central | W 24-7 | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1990 | Lycoming | W 21-14 (ot) | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Albion | W 24-21 (ot) | Meadville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Dayton | L 25-28 (ot) | Meadville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Mount Union | L 7-40 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Mount Union | L 19-28 | Meadville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Mount Union | L 26-31 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Mount Union | L 30-34 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Montclair State | L 19-20 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
Alma
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Wittenberg | L 19-42 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wheaton | L 14-42 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Carthage | L 28-31 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Mount St. Joseph | W 41-21 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Aurora | L 26-48 | Alma | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | DePauw | W 32-17 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Mount Union | W 24-20 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Cortland | L 41-58 | Alma | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wisconsin-Platteville | L 7-24 | Platteville | Second Round |
Anderson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Albion | L 21-41 | Albion | Regional |
Anna Maria
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Delaware Valley | L 10-62 | Doylestown | First Round |
Augsburg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 34-22 | Fargo | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Simpson | L 21-61 | Indianola | Quarterfinal |
Augustana
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | St. John's | L 7-46 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Dayton | L 7-19 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Baldwin Wallace | W 28-22 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1982 | St. Lawrence | W 14-0 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1982 | West Georgia | L 0-14 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Adrian | W 22-21 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1983 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 21-15 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1983 | Union | W 21-17 | Kings Mills | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Dayton | W 14-13 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1984 | Union | W 23-6 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1984 | Central | W 21-12 | Kings Mills | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Albion | W 26-10 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Mount Union | W 21-14 | Rock Island | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1985 | Central | W 14-7 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1985 | Ithaca | W 20-7 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Hope | W 34-10 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Mount Union | W 16-7 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1986 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 41-7 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 1986 | Salisbury | W 31-3 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Hiram | W 53-0 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Dayton | L 36-38 | Dayton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Adrian | W 25-7 | Rock Island | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Wittenberg | W 28-14 | Springfield | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1988 | Central | L 17-23 (ot) | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Millikin | L 12-21 | Decatur | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Dayton | L 14-24 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Albion | L 21-28 | Albion | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | St. Norbert | W 39-32 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Mount Union | L 33-42 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Defiance | W 54-14 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Mount Union | L 7-32 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Lakeland | W 49-22 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Mount Union | L 7-44 | Alliance | Second Round |
Aurora
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Illinois Wesleyan | L 12-21 | Bloomington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Wittenberg | L 20-31 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Wooster | L 34-41 | Wooster | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Monmouth | L 13-42 | Monmouth | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | St. John's | L 47-51 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Wheaton | L 31-63 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 33-28 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Alma | W 48-26 | Alma | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Wartburg | L 17-45 | Waverly | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Coe | W 20-7 | Aurora | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 35-56 | La Crosse | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Hope | L 21-49 | Holland | Second Round |
Baldwin Wallace
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | St. Lawrence | W 71-7 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1978 | Carnegie Mellon | W 31-6 | Berea | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1978 | Wittenberg | W 24-10 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Widener | L 8-29 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Dayton | L 0-34 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Augustana | L 22-28 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Dayton | L 10-27 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Hanover | W 54-32 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Wheaton | L 12-16 | Wheaton | Second Round |
Belhaven
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | North Central | L 0-65 | Naperville | First Round |
Benedictine
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | St. Thomas | L 10-57 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Mount Union | L 7-47 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wheaton | L 14-43 | Wheaton | First Round |
Berry
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Huntingdon | W 34-20 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | St. Thomas | L 13-29 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Maryville | W 31-0 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 9-75 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Huntingdon | L 24-27 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Maryville | L 16-20 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | LaGrange | W 18-14 | Mount Berry | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Trinity (TX) | W 31-23 | Mount Berry | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | John Carroll | L 13-21 | Mount Berry | Quarterfinal |
Bethany
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Widener | L 12-43 | Bethany | First Round |
Bethel
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Pacific Lutheran | L 13-41 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | L 27-37 | Stevens Point | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Wartburg | L 7-21 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 21-28 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Concordia (WI) | W 28-0 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | W 21-12 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Central | W 27-7 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2007 | Mount Union | L 14-62 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Wartburg | W 28-20 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Wheaton | W 15-10 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | St. Thomas | W 12-7 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2010 | Mount Union | L 14-34 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Concordia-Chicago | W 24-23 | River Forest | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 14-37 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | St. Scholastica | W 70-13 | Minneapolis | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Wartburg | W 34-27 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | North Central | L 17-41 | Arden Hills | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Wartburg | W 41-14 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | North Central | W 27-24 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 12-26 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Central | L 35-61 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Wheaton | W 34-32 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Linfield | W 30-13 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 28-41 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-42 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Coe | W 31-26 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Lake Forest | W 48-21 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Wartburg | W 24-14 | Waverly | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Susquehanna | L 21-24 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Coe | W 51-26 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Wisconsin-Platteville | W 35-24 | Arden Hills | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | North Central | L 21-35 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
Birmingham-Southern
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Huntingdon | W 24-14 | Birmingham | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-42 | Belton | Second Round |
Bishop
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Wartburg | W 32-7 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1982 | West Georgia | L 6-27 | Carrollton | Semifinal |
Bridgeport
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1973 | Juniata | L 14-35 | Bridgeport | Semifinal |
Bridgewater
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Washington and Jefferson | W 59-42 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Trinity (TX) | L 41-47 (ot) | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Trinity (TX) | W 41-37 | Bridgewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Widener | W 57-32 | Bridgewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2001 | Rowan | W 29-24 | Bridgewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 15, 2001 | Mount Union | L 27-30 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | King's | W 19-17 | Bridgewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Trinity (TX) | L 32-38 | Bridgewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Waynesburg | W 28-24 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Christopher Newport | W 26-3 | Newport News | Second Round |
| Sun., Dec. 7, 2003 | Lycoming | W 13-9 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2003 | Mount Union | L 0-66 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Washington and Jefferson | L 48-55 (ot) | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Washington and Jefferson | W 30-21 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Thiel | W 24-13 | Greenville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Wesley | L 7-46 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Delaware Valley | L 22-30 | Bridgewater | First Round |
Bridgewater State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Ursinus | L 38-43 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Hobart | L 0-25 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Widener | L 14-44 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Alfred | L 27-33 (ot) | Alfred | First Round |
Brockport
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Springfield | L 6-13 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Rowan | L 17-40 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Springfield | W 16-0 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Rowan | W 15-12 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | John Carroll | L 10-16 (ot) | Rochester | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Ithaca | L 9-14 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Plymouth State | W 66-0 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Wesley | W 49-28 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Delaware Valley | W 31-28 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2017 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 0-24 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Framingham State | W 40-27 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | RPI | L 13-21 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Western New England | W 33-28 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Muhlenberg | L 0-42 | Allentown | Second Round |
Buena Vista
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | Carroll | W 20-14 (ot) | Waukesha | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1976 | St. John's | L 0-61 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Central | L 0-37 | Storm Lake | First Round |
Buffalo State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Ithaca | W 28-26 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Rowan | L 19-28 | Buffalo | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Rowan | L 6-29 | Glassboro | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Ithaca | L 7-10 (ot) | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Rowan | L 7-46 | Buffalo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Rowan | L 20-21 | Buffalo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Springfield | W 38-35 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Rowan | L 17-19 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Montclair State | L 34-37 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
C.W. Post
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | Towson State | L 10-14 | Brookville | First Round |
California Lutheran
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Linfield | L 17-38 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Linfield | L 26-42 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Linfield | L 27-30 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | North Central | L 21-41 | Thousand Oaks | First Round |
Capital
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Dayton | L 28-52 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | North Central | W 21-19 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Wabash | W 14-11 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Mount Union | L 31-34 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wittenberg | W 32-14 | Bexley | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | North Central | W 41-13 | Bexley | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Mount Union | L 14-17 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-34 | Whitewater | First Round |
Carleton
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Central | L 8-20 | Pella | Regional |
Carnegie Mellon
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Dayton | W 24-21 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1978 | Baldwin Wallace | L 6-31 | Berea | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Minnesota-Morris | W 31-25 (ot) | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1979 | Ithaca | L 6-15 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Salisbury | L 14-16 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Salisbury | L 22-35 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Lycoming | L 7-17 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Millsaps | W 21-0 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wesley | L 0-37 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | DePauw | W 45-14 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | North Central | L 7-28 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Centre | W 24-15 | Pittsburgh | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Mount Union | L 19-24 | Alliance | Third Round |
Carroll
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | Buena Vista | L 14-20 (ot) | Waukesha | First Round |
Carthage
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Alma | W 31-28 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Wooster | W 14-7 | Wooster | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Mount Union | L 20-38 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
Case Western Reserve
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Widener | W 21-20 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Wabash | L 23-38 | Cleveland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wabash | L 17-20 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Trine | L 38-51 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 28-0 | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Mount Union | L 16-45 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Union | L 21-24 | Schenectady | First Round |
Catholic
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Trinity (TX) | L 33-44 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Lycoming | L 14-49 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Western Maryland | L 16-20 | Westminster | First Round |
Central
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1974 | Evansville | W 17-16 | Evansville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1974 | Ithaca | W 10-8 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Widener | L 0-19 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Occidental | W 23-22 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1984 | Washington and Jefferson | W 20-0 | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1984 | Augustana | L 12-21 | Kings Mills | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Coe | W 27-7 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Occidental | W 71-0 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1985 | Augustana | L 7-14 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Buena Vista | W 37-0 | Storm Lake | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Concordia-Moorhead | L 14-17 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Menlo | W 17-0 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | St. John's | W 13-3 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1987 | Dayton | L 0-34 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 7-0 | Moorhead | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 16-13 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1988 | Augustana | W 23-17 (ot) | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 1988 | Ithaca | L 24-39 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | St. Norbert | W 55-7 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | St. John's | L 24-27 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Redlands | W 24-14 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | St. Thomas | W 33-32 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1990 | Allegheny | L 7-24 | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Carleton | W 20-8 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 9-34 | Ames | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Wartburg | L 21-22 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 7-10 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | L 21-28 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 38-17 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | St. John's | L 9-10 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | St. Norbert | W 29-14 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Linfield | W 20-17 (ot) | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | St. John's | L 18-21 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Pacific Lutheran | L 21-27 (ot) | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-34 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | St. John's | L 13-21 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Olivet | W 38-17 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | St. John's | W 37-7 | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Bethel | L 7-27 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 40-42 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | W 38-37 (ot) | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Wheaton | L 13-49 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Bethel | W 61-35 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Wheaton | W 30-28 | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-51 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
Centre
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Hampden-Sydney | W 51-41 | Danville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Mount Union | L 10-30 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | John Carroll | L 28-63 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Washington and Jefferson | W 54-13 | Danville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Mount Union | L 35-51 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Carnegie Mellon | L 15-24 | Pittsburgh | Second Round |
Chapman
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Linfield | L 24-55 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 6-50 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Linfield | W 68-65 (ot) | Orange | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | St. John's | L 26-55 | Orange | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Whitworth | L 28-42 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Whitworth | W 18-16 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 7-58 | River Falls | Second Round |
Christopher Newport
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Widener | L 7-56 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Washington and Jefferson | L 10-24 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Muhlenberg | W 24-20 | Newport News | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Bridgewater | L 3-26 | Newport News | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Salisbury | W 35-24 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Washington and Jefferson | L 14-24 | Washington | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Washington and Jefferson | L 23-27 | Newport News | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Washington and Jefferson | L 29-35 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-59 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Kean | L 10-34 | Union | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Mount Union | L 14-72 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Delaware Valley | W 29-26 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Widener | L 27-37 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Randolph-Macon | L 20-28 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Susquehanna | L 28-42 | Newport News | Second Round |
Claremont-Mudd-Scripps
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Whitworth | L 6-48 | Spokane | First Round |
Coast Guard
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | College of New Jersey | L 16-17 | Ewing | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Rowan | L 0-43 | Glassboro | First Round |
Coe
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Central | L 7-27 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | St. John's | L 2-75 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | St. John's | L 14-32 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 21-18 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | St. John's | L 14-45 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Concordia-Moorhead | L 14-27 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | St. John's | W 34-27 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | St. Thomas | L 7-34 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Wheaton | L 21-31 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Elmhurst | L 24-27 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Monmouth | W 21-14 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | St. Thomas | L 6-55 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Aurora | L 7-20 | Aurora | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Bethel | L 26-31 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Concordia (WI) | W 44-7 | Mequon | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Bethel | L 26-51 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
Colorado College
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Millsaps | L 21-28 | Colorado Springs | First Round |
Concordia (WI)
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 13-52 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | North Central | L 6-35 | Milwaukee | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Bethel | L 0-28 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Wisconsin-Platteville | L 20-54 | Platteville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Coe | L 7-44 | Mequon | First Round |
Concordia-Chicago
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Bethel | L 23-24 | River Forest | First Round |
Concordia-Moorhead
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | W 24-15 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Central | W 17-14 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1986 | Augustana | L 7-41 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Central | L 0-7 | Moorhead | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 7-45 | Fargo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Augsburg | L 22-34 | Fargo | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Wartburg | W 28-14 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Occidental | L 40-42 | Fargo | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Coe | W 27-14 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Linfield | L 14-28 | McMinnville | Second Round |
Cortland
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Hofstra | W 32-27 | Cortland | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Ithaca | L 17-24 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Union | L 14-42 | Schenectady | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Hofstra | L 9-35 | Hempstead | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | College of New Jersey | L 30-34 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Hobart | L 22-23 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Plymouth State | W 31-14 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Curry | W 42-0 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Mount Union | L 14-41 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Endicott | W 49-35 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Alfred | L 20-34 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Framingham State | W 20-19 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Wesley | L 6-56 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Salisbury | W 45-21 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Linfield | L 22-38 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Springfield | W 26-21 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | RPI | L 14-21 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Randolph-Macon | L 28-35 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Endicott | W 23-17 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Grove City | W 25-24 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Alma | W 58-41 | Alma | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2023 | Randolph-Macon | W 49-14 | Ashland | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 15, 2023 | North Central | W 38-37 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Endicott | W 17-9 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Springfield | L 28-40 | Cortland | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Springfield | L 7-21 | Springfield | First Round |
Crown
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Wheaton | L 14-76 | Wheaton | First Round |
Curry
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | RPI | L 20-34 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Hobart | L 16-35 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Delaware Valley | L 22-37 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Springfield | L 14-42 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Hartwick | W 42-21 | Milton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | St. John Fisher | L 7-38 | Pittsford | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Ithaca | W 26-21 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Cortland | L 0-42 | Cortland | Second Round |
Dayton
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Carnegie Mellon | L 21-24 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Baldwin Wallace | W 34-0 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1980 | Widener | W 28-24 | Chester | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1980 | Ithaca | W 63-0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Augustana | W 19-7 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1981 | Lawrence | W 38-0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1981 | Widener | L 10-17 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Augustana | L 13-14 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Mount Union | L 36-42 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Capital | W 52-28 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Augustana | W 38-36 | Dayton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1987 | Central | W 34-0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1987 | Wagner | L 3-19 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Wittenberg | L 28-35 (ot) | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | John Carroll | W 35-10 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Millikin | W 28-16 | Dayton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1989 | St. John's | W 28-0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 1989 | Union | W 17-7 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Augustana | W 24-14 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Allegheny | L 23-31 | Meadville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Baldwin Wallace | W 27-10 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Allegheny | W 28-25 (ot) | Meadville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1991 | St. John's | W 19-7 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1991 | Ithaca | L 20-34 | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Mount Union | L 10-27 | Dayton | Regional |
Defiance
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Augustana | L 14-54 | Rock Island | First Round |
Delaware Valley
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Shenandoah | W 21-17 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | St. John Fisher | W 26-20 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Rowan | L 7-56 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Curry | W 37-22 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Hobart | W 21-14 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Rowan | L 21-27 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Susquehanna | W 66-7 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Albright | L 3-27 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Salisbury | W 23-12 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Mount Union | L 3-31 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Norwich | W 62-10 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | St. John Fisher | L 14-27 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Christopher Newport | L 26-29 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Western New England | W 35-0 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Husson | W 37-15 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Brockport | L 28-31 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Muhlenberg | L 13-20 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Bridgewater | W 30-22 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Wesley | W 45-10 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | North Central | L 14-31 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Anna Maria | W 62-10 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Muhlenberg | L 0-14 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Gallaudet | W 59-0 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Randolph-Macon | W 39-32 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Mount Union | L 6-22 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Union | L 16-24 | Doylestown | First Round |
Denison
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Mount Union | L 3-35 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Mount Union | L 0-60 | Alliance | First Round |
DePauw
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Thomas More | L 39-49 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Trine | L 35-45 | Greencastle | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Rose-Hulman | W 26-21 | Greencastle | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 0-45 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Carnegie Mellon | L 14-45 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Alma | L 17-32 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Maryville | W 45-20 | Greencastle | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Johns Hopkins | L 9-14 | Greencastle | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 26-23 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Wheaton | L 24-49 | Greencastle | Third Round |
Dickinson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Lycoming | L 0-21 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Susquehanna | L 20-21 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Widener | L 0-14 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wesley | L 21-49 | Dover | First Round |
Dubuque
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Ithaca | L 7-27 | Dubuque | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Minnesota-Morris | L 35-41 | Morris | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | North Central | L 13-59 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | St. John's | L 7-51 | Collegeville | First Round |
East Texas Baptist
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Trinity (TX) | W 42-41 (ot) | Marshall | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Lycoming | L 7-13 (ot) | Williamsport | Second Round |
Eastern
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Franklin and Marshall | W 28-24 | Lancaster | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Susquehanna | L 0-29 | St. Davids | Third Round |
Elmhurst
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Coe | W 27-24 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | St. Thomas | L 17-24 | St. Paul | Second Round |
Emory and Henry
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Salisbury | L 20-34 | Bristol | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Ferrum | W 49-7 | Roanoke | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Washington and Jefferson | W 23-16 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1987 | Wagner | L 15-20 | Emory | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Thomas More | W 17-0 | Emory | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Washington and Jefferson | L 15-51 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Washington and Jefferson | L 16-35 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Western Maryland | L 14-38 | Emory | First Round |
Endicott
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Cortland | L 35-49 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Rowan | L 0-24 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | RPI | L 14-20 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Springfield | L 14-17 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Cortland | L 17-23 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Alfred State | W 44-0 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Cortland | L 9-17 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Salisbury | L 28-35 | Salisbury | Second Round |
Eureka
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | St. Thomas | L 8-47 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-67 | Whitewater | First Round |
Evansville
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1974 | Central | L 16-17 | Evansville | Semifinal |
Ferrum
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Emory and Henry | L 7-49 | Roanoke | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Rhodes | W 34-10 | Rocky Mount | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Moravian | W 49-28 | Rocky Mount | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1988 | Ithaca | L 28-62 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Washington and Jefferson | W 41-7 | Rocky Mount | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Lycoming | W 49-24 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1989 | Union | L 21-37 | Rocky Mount | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Washington and Jefferson | L 7-10 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Wesley | L 14-59 | Dover | First Round |
Fordham
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Hofstra | W 41-6 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Wagner | L 0-21 | Bronx | Quarterfinal |
Fort Valley State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Ithaca | L 12-41 | Ithaca | First Round |
Framingham State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Cortland | L 19-20 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Ithaca | L 17-20 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wesley | L 22-42 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Brockport | L 27-40 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wesley | L 21-58 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Muhlenberg | L 0-45 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | LaGrange | L 21-24 | Framingham | First Round |
Franklin
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | North Central | L 42-44 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Otterbein | W 62-45 | Westerville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | North Central | W 38-28 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Wheaton | L 28-45 | Franklin | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-52 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Thomas More | W 24-21 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-41 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Adrian | W 42-10 | Adrian | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 17-63 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Washington | W 17-10 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 3-33 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wabash | L 14-33 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Ohio Northern | L 22-27 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Wartburg | L 34-35 (ot) | Waverly | First Round |
Franklin and Marshall
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Eastern | L 24-28 | Lancaster | Second Round |
Frostburg State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Wilkes | W 26-25 | Wilkes-Barre | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Washington and Jefferson | L 7-28 | Frostburg | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Wittenberg | W 35-7 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Washington and Jefferson | W 46-23 | Washington | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Mount Union | L 37-70 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Western New England | W 42-24 | Frostburg | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Johns Hopkins | L 27-58 | Frostburg | Second Round |
Gallaudet
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Hobart | L 7-34 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Delaware Valley | L 0-59 | Doylestown | First Round |
Gettysburg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Lycoming | W 14-10 | Gettysburg | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Salisbury | W 22-6 | Gettysburg | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1985 | Ithaca | L 0-34 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
Greenville
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-69 | Whitewater | First Round |
Grove City
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Susquehanna | W 21-20 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Cortland | L 24-25 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Johns Hopkins | L 14-17 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Hanover | L 15-23 | Hanover | First Round |
Gustavus Adolphus
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | St. John's | L 3-7 | St. Peter | First Round |
Hampden-Sydney
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Albany | L 45-51 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Wesley | L 17-45 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Johns Hopkins | L 7-23 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Montclair State | L 14-16 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Centre | L 41-51 | Danville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Maryville | W 42-34 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Linfield | L 21-31 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wesley | L 7-52 | Dover | First Round |
Hanover
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Mount Union | L 18-52 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | John Carroll | L 20-30 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Ohio Northern | L 14-56 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Hope | W 20-3 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Wittenberg | L 21-32 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wittenberg | L 33-34 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Baldwin Wallace | L 32-54 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | North Central | L 0-52 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Mount Union | L 14-65 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Grove City | W 23-15 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | North Central | L 6-38 | Naperville | Second Round |
Hardin-Simmons
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Washington | W 28-21 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Washington and Jefferson | W 51-3 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Trinity (TX) | L 33-40 | San Antonio | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Western Maryland | W 32-10 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Trinity (TX) | W 33-30 | Abilene | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2000 | St. John's | L 14-38 | Abilene | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Wittenberg | L 35-38 (ot) | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 28-42 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 21-33 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 35-38 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 19-37 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Linfield | L 10-24 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Linfield | L 13-27 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 6-27 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Trinity (TX) | L 7-14 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Trinity (TX) | L 6-20 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 13-17 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Trinity (TX) | L 24-34 | San Antonio | Second Round |
Hartwick
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Curry | L 21-42 | Milton | First Round |
Heidelberg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Wittenberg | L 38-52 | Tiffin | First Round |
Hendrix
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Huntingdon | L 27-38 | Montgomery | First Round |
Hiram
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Augustana | L 0-53 | Rock Island | First Round |
Hobart
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Bridgewater State | W 25-0 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Widener | L 14-40 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | John Carroll | L 7-27 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Curry | W 35-16 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Rowan | L 14-45 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Cortland | W 23-22 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Delaware Valley | L 14-21 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Rowan | #L 18-20 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | St. John Fisher | #L 7-24 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Lycoming | W 33-15 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Mount Union | L 7-42 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Wesley | L 28-35 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Washington and Lee | W 38-20 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Wittenberg | W 35-10 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | St. Thomas | L 7-47 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Gallaudet | W 34-7 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | St. John Fisher | L 6-27 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Ithaca | W 22-15 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Johns Hopkins | W 24-21 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Wesley | L 13-41 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Mount Union | L 21-38 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Susquehanna | L 35-42 | Selinsgrove | Second Round |
Hofstra
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Union | L 19-51 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Montclair State | L 21-24 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Fordham | L 6-41 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Cortland | L 27-32 | Cortland | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Montclair State | L 6-23 | Upper Montclair | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Cortland | W 35-9 | Hempstead | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Trenton State | W 38-3 | Ewing | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1990 | Lycoming | L 10-20 | Hempstead | Semifinal |
Hope
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Augustana | L 10-34 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Hanover | L 3-20 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Wheaton | L 45-55 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Mount Union | L 0-49 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wartburg | L 3-41 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Aurora | W 49-21 | Holland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | North Central | L 21-41 | Naperville | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 7-9 | Holland | Second Round |
Huntingdon
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Mississippi College | L 35-56 | Montgomery | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Hendrix | W 38-27 | Montgomery | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 23-43 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wheaton | L 10-45 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Berry | L 20-34 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Berry | W 27-24 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 6-42 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Birmingham-Southern | L 14-24 | Birmingham | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 0-54 | Belton | First Round |
Husson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | MIT | L 20-27 (ot) | Bangor | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Western New England | L 27-44 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Springfield | W 23-21 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Delaware Valley | L 15-37 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | RPI | L 14-38 | Troy | First Round |
Illinois College
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Wabash | L 20-38 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Wartburg | L 14-49 | Waverly | First Round |
Illinois Wesleyan
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Aurora | W 21-12 | Bloomington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Mount Union | L 27-49 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Albion | W 23-20 | Albion | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Mount Union | L 14-49 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Wabash | W 41-35 (ot) | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-45 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Monmouth | L 27-33 (ot) | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Wartburg | L 7-41 | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Case Western Reserve | L 0-28 | Bloomington | First Round |
Indianapolis
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Wittenberg | L 13-17 | Springfield | First Round |
Ithaca
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1974 | Slippery Rock | W 27-14 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1974 | Central | L 8-10 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Fort Valley State | W 41-12 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1975 | Widener | W 23-14 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1975 | Wittenberg | L 0-28 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Wittenberg | L 3-6 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Dubuque | W 27-7 | Dubuque | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1979 | Carnegie Mellon | W 15-6 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1979 | Wittenberg | W 14-10 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Wagner | W 41-13 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1980 | Minnesota-Morris | W 36-0 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1980 | Dayton | L 0-63 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Union | W 13-12 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Montclair State | W 50-28 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1985 | Gettysburg | W 34-0 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1985 | Augustana | L 7-20 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Union | W 24-17 (ot) | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Montclair State | W 29-15 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1986 | Salisbury | L 40-44 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Wagner | W 34-31 (ot) | Staten Island | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Cortland | W 24-17 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1988 | Ferrum | W 62-28 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 1988 | Central | W 39-24 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Trenton State | L 14-24 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Glassboro State | W 31-10 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Union | W 35-23 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1991 | Susquehanna | W 49-13 | Selinsgrove | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1991 | Dayton | W 34-20 | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Buffalo State | L 26-28 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Buffalo State | W 10-7 (ot) | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Plymouth State | W 22-7 | Plymouth | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1994 | Washington and Jefferson | L 19-23 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Montclair State | W 35-23 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | RPI | W 27-10 | Troy | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Rowan | L 0-48 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Brockport | W 14-9 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Montclair State | W 33-13 | Upper Montclair | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | RPI | L 16-21 | Troy | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Union | L 41-55 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Mount Union | L 18-42 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Curry | L 21-26 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Framingham State | W 20-17 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Wesley | L 15-23 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Hobart | L 15-22 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Massachusetts-Dartmouth | W 63-20 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Springfield | W 31-20 | Ithaca | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | North Central | L 7-48 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Springfield | W 21-7 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Randolph-Macon | L 0-46 | Ashland | Second Round |
John Carroll
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Dayton | L 10-35 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Hanover | W 30-20 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Mount Union | L 7-59 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Hobart | W 27-7 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Muhlenberg | W 21-10 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Brockport | W 16-10 (ot) | Rochester | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2002 | Mount Union | L 19-57 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | St. John Fisher | L 16-25 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Centre | W 63-28 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wheaton | W 14-12 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Mount Union | L 28-36 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Olivet | W 37-12 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Wesley | W 20-17 (ot) | Cleveland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 31-14 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2016 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 3-10 | Oshkosh | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Randolph-Macon | L 20-23 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Mount St. Joseph | W 52-7 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Mount Union | L 7-42 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Randolph-Macon | W 35-6 | Cleveland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Mount Union | W 10-7 (ot) | Alliance | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Berry | W 21-13 | Mount Berry | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2025 | North Central | L 21-41 | Naperville | Semifinal |
Johns Hopkins
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Thiel | L 3-28 | Greenville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Hampden-Sydney | W 23-7 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Thomas More | W 31-29 | Crestview Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Wesley | L 0-12 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | St. John Fisher | L 12-23 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Washington and Jefferson | W 42-10 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Mount Union | L 13-55 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Wesley | L 24-29 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Rowan | W 24-16 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Hobart | L 21-24 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Western New England | W 52-20 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Wesley | L 37-42 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Randolph-Macon | W 42-21 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Mount Union | L 21-28 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Washington and Jefferson | L 28-31 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | MIT | W 49-0 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Frostburg State | W 58-27 | Frostburg | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | RPI | W 37-14 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2018 | Mount Union | L 20-28 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Salisbury | W 45-20 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Mount Union | L 35-45 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Western Connecticut | W 62-20 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Union | W 39-17 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Randolph-Macon | L 36-39 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Grove City | W 17-14 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | DePauw | W 14-9 | Greencastle | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 17-10 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2024 | Mount Union | L 37-45 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Springfield | W 34-14 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Salisbury | W 45-13 | Baltimore | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Susquehanna | W 40-10 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2025 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 41-48 | River Falls | Semifinal |
Juniata
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1973 | Bridgeport | W 35-14 | Bridgeport | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1973 | Wittenberg | L 0-41 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
Kean
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Christopher Newport | W 34-10 | Union | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Salisbury | L 47-49 (ot) | Salisbury | Second Round |
King's
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Salisbury | W 28-0 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Bridgewater | L 17-19 | Bridgewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Ursinus | W 32-29 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Salisbury | L 13-33 | Salisbury | Second Round |
La Verne
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | St. John's | L 12-51 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | St. Thomas | L 14-57 | St. Paul | First Round |
LaGrange
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Millsaps | L 26-51 | Jackson | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Framingham State | W 24-21 | Framingham | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Berry | L 14-18 | Mount Berry | Second Round |
Lake Forest
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wartburg | L 0-45 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | St. John's | L 14-41 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | North Central | L 0-50 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Bethel | L 21-48 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
Lakeland
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Augustana | L 22-49 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-70 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wheaton | L 6-55 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 27-45 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 0-63 | Oshkosh | First Round |
Lawrence
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Minnesota-Morris | W 21-14 (ot) | Appleton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1981 | Dayton | L 0-38 | Dayton | Semifinal |
Lebanon Valley
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Wittenberg | L 17-59 | Springfield | First Round |
Linfield
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Central | L 17-20 (ot) | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Wartburg | W 52-15 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | St. John's | L 14-21 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Redlands | W 31-23 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Wartburg | W 23-20 | Salem | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | St. John's | L 25-31 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 52-14 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Occidental | W 56-27 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2004 | Rowan | W 52-0 | McMinnville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 2004 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 28-21 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Occidental | W 63-21 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 28-14 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 41-44 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | California Lutheran | W 38-17 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 53-21 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | St. Thomas | W 31-20 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 17-27 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | California Lutheran | W 42-26 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | St. Thomas | L 17-24 (ot) | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | California Lutheran | W 30-27 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Wesley | L 34-49 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Pacific Lutheran | W 27-24 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | North Central | W 30-14 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 24-31 (ot) | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Pacific Lutheran | W 42-21 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Hampden-Sydney | W 31-21 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 17-28 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Chapman | W 55-24 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 31-28 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Widener | W 45-7 | Chester | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2014 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-20 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Whitworth | W 48-10 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Cortland | W 38-22 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 38-35 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2015 | St. Thomas | L 17-38 | St. Paul | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Hardin-Simmons | W 24-10 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 10-27 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Hardin-Simmons | W 27-13 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 0-24 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Chapman | L 65-68 (ot) | Orange | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Redlands | W 44-10 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | St. John's | W 31-28 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 24-49 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Pomona-Pitzer | W 51-24 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Bethel | L 13-30 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Texas Lutheran | W 65-3 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 18-28 | McMinnville | Third Round |
Louisiana College
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 20-59 | Belton | First Round |
Lycoming
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Gettysburg | L 10-14 | Gettysburg | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Dickinson | W 21-0 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Ferrum | L 24-49 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Carnegie Mellon | W 17-7 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Washington and Jefferson | W 24-0 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1990 | Hofstra | W 20-10 | Hempstead | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1990 | Allegheny | L 14-21 (ot) | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Washington and Jefferson | W 18-16 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Susquehanna | L 24-31 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Washington and Jefferson | L 0-33 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Widener | W 31-27 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Washington and Jefferson | L 0-48 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Ursinus | W 31-24 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Albright | W 31-13 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1996 | Rowan | L 14-33 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Western Maryland | W 27-13 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Trinity (TX) | W 46-26 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1997 | Rowan | W 28-20 | Williamsport | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 1997 | Mount Union | L 12-61 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Catholic | W 49-14 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Trinity (TX) | L 21-37 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Washington and Jefferson | L 7-14 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | East Texas Baptist | W 13-7 (ot) | Williamsport | Second Round |
| Sun., Dec. 7, 2003 | Bridgewater | L 9-13 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Hobart | L 15-33 | Geneva | First Round |
Macalester
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 2-55 | Whitewater | First Round |
MacMurray
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Thomas More | L 30-34 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wabash | L 7-42 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
Maine Maritime
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Montclair State | L 22-38 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
Maritime College
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Alfred | L 0-60 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Salisbury | L 0-83 | Salisbury | First Round |
Martin Luther
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | St. John's | L 6-84 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wheaton | L 7-51 | Wheaton | First Round |
Mary Hardin-Baylor
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Trinity (TX) | L 6-30 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Trinity (TX) | L 38-48 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Trinity (TX) | W 32-13 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Hardin-Simmons | W 42-28 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Washington and Jefferson | W 52-16 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2004 | Mount Union | W 38-35 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 2004 | Linfield | L 21-28 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Trinity (TX) | W 35-6 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Wesley | L 36-46 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Hardin-Simmons | W 33-21 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Washington and Jefferson | W 30-27 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Wesley | L 20-34 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Trinity (TX) | W 52-23 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | North Carolina Wesleyan | W 64-0 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Wesley | W 27-10 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-16 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Hardin-Simmons | W 38-35 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Wesley | W 46-14 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Washington and Jefferson | W 63-7 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2008 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 13-39 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Central | W 42-40 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Linfield | L 21-53 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Christopher Newport | W 59-7 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Thomas More | W 69-7 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Wesley | L 9-19 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Redlands | W 34-13 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | McMurry | W 49-20 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Wesley | L 24-27 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Louisiana College | W 59-20 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Franklin | W 63-17 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Wesley | W 32-20 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2012 | Mount Union | L 35-48 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Redlands | W 35-7 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Rowan | W 59-8 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | St. John Fisher | W 45-23 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2013 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 15-16 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Texas Lutheran | W 27-20 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Linfield | L 28-31 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Hardin-Simmons | W 37-19 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Huntingdon | W 43-23 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Linfield | L 35-38 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Redlands | #W 50-28 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Linfield | #W 27-10 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Wheaton | #W 38-16 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2016 | Mount Union | #W 14-12 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2016 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | #W 10-7 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Chapman | #W 50-6 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Linfield | #W 24-0 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | St. Thomas | #W 24-10 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2017 | Brockport | #W 24-0 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 15, 2017 | Mount Union | #L 0-12 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Hardin-Simmons | W 27-6 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Berry | W 75-9 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | St. John's | W 21-18 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2018 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 31-14 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 14, 2018 | Mount Union | W 24-16 | Shenandoah | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Redlands | W 43-14 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Huntingdon | W 42-6 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-26 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Trinity (TX) | W 13-3 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Birmingham-Southern | W 42-7 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Linfield | W 49-24 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2021 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 24-7 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 17, 2021 | North Central | W 57-24 | Canton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Huntingdon | W 54-0 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Trinity (TX) | W 24-17 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Bethel | W 41-28 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2022 | North Central | L 14-49 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Trinity (TX) | W 29-22 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Hardin-Simmons | W 17-13 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Linfield | W 28-18 | McMinnville | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Johns Hopkins | L 10-17 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
Maryville
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Hampden-Sydney | L 34-42 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Berry | L 0-31 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Berry | W 20-16 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | DePauw | L 20-45 | Greencastle | Second Round |
MIT
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Husson | W 27-20 (ot) | Bangor | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wesley | L 0-59 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Johns Hopkins | L 0-49 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Muhlenberg | L 0-38 | Allentown | First Round |
Massachusetts-Dartmouth
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Muhlenberg | L 6-56 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Ithaca | L 20-63 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Springfield | L 27-54 | Springfield | Second Round |
Massachusetts-Lowell
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Union | L 16-55 | Schenectady | Regional |
McDaniel
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Lycoming | L 13-27 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Trinity (TX) | L 20-30 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Catholic | W 20-16 | Westminster | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Trinity (TX) | L 16-20 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Emory and Henry | W 38-14 | Emory | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Hardin-Simmons | L 10-32 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Washington and Jefferson | L 21-24 | Washington | First Round |
McMurry
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Trinity (TX) | W 25-16 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 20-49 | Belton | Second Round |
Menlo
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Central | L 0-17 | Pella | First Round |
Merchant Marine
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Plymouth State | L 18-19 | Plymouth | Regional |
Millersville
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Wittenberg | L 14-21 | Millersville | First Round |
Millikin
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Augustana | W 21-12 | Decatur | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Dayton | L 16-28 | Dayton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Wittenberg | L 10-13 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Ohio Northern | L 21-47 | Ada | First Round |
Millsaps
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Colorado College | W 28-21 | Colorado Springs | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1975 | Wittenberg | L 22-55 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Carnegie Mellon | L 0-21 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | LaGrange | W 51-26 | Jackson | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Washington and Jefferson | L 20-35 | Jackson | Second Round |
Minnesota-Morris
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Albion | W 13-10 | Morris | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1977 | Wabash | L 21-37 | Crawfordsville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | St. Olaf | W 23-10 | Morris | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1978 | Wittenberg | L 14-35 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Carnegie Mellon | L 25-31 (ot) | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Dubuque | W 41-35 | Morris | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1980 | Ithaca | L 0-36 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Lawrence | L 14-21 (ot) | Appleton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 7-62 | La Crosse | First Round |
Mississippi College
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Huntingdon | W 56-35 | Montgomery | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Wesley | L 9-43 | Dover | Second Round |
Monmouth
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | St. John's | L 3-62 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Aurora | W 42-13 | Monmouth | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Wartburg | L 28-30 | Monmouth | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | St. Thomas | L 21-43 | Monmouth | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 33-27 (ot) | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | St. Thomas | L 10-38 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Coe | L 14-21 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Trine | L 24-63 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 10-35 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | St. John's | L 15-49 | Collegeville | Second Round |
Montclair State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Alfred | W 13-12 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1981 | Widener | L 12-23 | Chester | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Western Connecticut | W 28-0 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Ithaca | L 28-50 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Hofstra | W 24-21 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Ithaca | L 15-29 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Hofstra | W 23-6 | Upper Montclair | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Union | L 6-45 | Schenectady | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Buffalo State | W 37-34 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Western Connecticut | W 32-24 | Danbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Rowan | L 13-42 | Upper Montclair | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Springfield | L 29-31 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Ithaca | L 23-35 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Allegheny | W 20-19 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Ithaca | L 13-33 | Upper Montclair | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Maine Maritime | W 38-22 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Mount Union | L 14-62 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Hampden-Sydney | W 16-14 | Hampden-Sydney | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Wesley | L 7-44 | Dover | Second Round |
Moravian
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Widener | W 17-7 | Bethlehem | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Ferrum | L 28-49 | Rocky Mount | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Washington and Jefferson | L 7-27 | Washington | Regional |
Mount Ida
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Wesley | L 14-73 | Dover | First Round |
Mount St. Joseph
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Wheaton | L 7-31 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Mount Union | L 6-49 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wheaton | L 28-42 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Wabash | L 21-31 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Wittenberg | L 14-42 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Alma | L 21-41 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Wheaton | L 34-41 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | John Carroll | L 7-52 | Cleveland | First Round |
Mount Union
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Denison | W 35-3 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Augustana | L 14-21 | Rock Island | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Dayton | W 42-36 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Augustana | L 7-16 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Allegheny | L 15-26 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Dayton | W 27-10 | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 49-27 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 24-29 | La Crosse | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Allegheny | W 40-7 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Albion | W 30-16 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1993 | St. John's | W 56-8 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1993 | Rowan | W 34-24 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Allegheny | W 28-19 | Meadville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Albion | L 33-34 | Albion | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Hanover | W 52-18 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Wheaton | W 40-14 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1995 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 17-20 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Allegheny | W 31-26 | Alliance | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 49-14 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1996 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 39-21 | Madison | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1996 | Rowan | W 56-24 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Allegheny | W 34-30 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | John Carroll | W 59-7 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1997 | Simpson | W 54-7 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 1997 | Lycoming | W 61-12 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Albion | W 21-19 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Wittenberg | W 21-19 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1998 | Trinity (TX) | W 34-29 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1998 | Rowan | W 44-24 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Augustana | W 42-33 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Ohio Northern | W 56-31 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1999 | Rowan | L 17-24 (ot) | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Ohio Northern | W 59-28 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Wittenberg | W 32-15 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2000 | Widener | W 70-30 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 16, 2000 | St. John's | W 10-7 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Augustana | W 32-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Wittenberg | W 49-21 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2001 | St. John's | W 35-14 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 15, 2001 | Bridgewater | W 30-27 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Wheaton | W 42-21 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Wabash | W 45-16 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2002 | John Carroll | W 57-19 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2002 | Trinity (TX) | W 48-7 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 39-14 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | Wheaton | W 56-10 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2003 | Bridgewater | W 66-0 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2003 | St. John's | L 6-24 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Wheaton | W 27-6 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Carthage | W 38-20 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2004 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 35-38 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Mount St. Joseph | W 49-6 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Augustana | W 44-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Capital | W 34-31 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2005 | Rowan | W 19-7 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 17, 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 35-28 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Hope | W 49-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wheaton | W 35-3 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Capital | W 17-14 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2006 | St. John Fisher | W 26-14 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 16, 2006 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 35-16 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Ithaca | W 42-18 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | College of New Jersey | W 59-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | St. John Fisher | W 52-10 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2007 | Bethel | W 62-14 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 15, 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-31 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Randolph-Macon | W 56-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Hobart | W 42-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Cortland | W 41-14 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2008 | Wheaton | W 45-24 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2008 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 31-26 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Washington and Jefferson | W 55-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Montclair State | W 62-14 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Albright | W 55-3 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2009 | Wesley | W 24-7 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 19, 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 28-38 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | St. Lawrence | W 49-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Delaware Valley | W 31-3 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Alfred | W 37-7 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2010 | Bethel | W 34-14 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 2010 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-31 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Benedictine | W 47-7 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Centre | W 30-10 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Wabash | W 20-8 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2011 | Wesley | W 28-21 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 10-13 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Christopher Newport | W 72-14 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Johns Hopkins | W 55-13 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Widener | W 72-17 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2012 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 48-35 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 14, 2012 | St. Thomas | W 28-10 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Washington and Jefferson | W 34-20 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Wittenberg | W 56-21 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Wesley | W 62-59 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2013 | North Central | W 41-40 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 20, 2013 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-52 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Adrian | W 63-3 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Washington and Jefferson | W 67-0 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | John Carroll | W 36-28 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2014 | Wesley | W 70-21 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 19, 2014 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 34-43 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | St. Lawrence | W 55-23 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Albright | W 66-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Wesley | W 56-35 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2015 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 36-6 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 18, 2015 | St. Thomas | W 49-35 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Hobart | W 38-21 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Johns Hopkins | W 28-21 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Alfred | W 70-45 | Alfred | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2016 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 12-14 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Washington and Lee | W 21-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Case Western Reserve | W 45-16 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Frostburg State | W 70-37 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2017 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | W 43-40 | Oshkosh | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 15, 2017 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 12-0 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Denison | W 60-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Centre | W 51-35 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Muhlenberg | W 38-10 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2018 | Johns Hopkins | W 28-20 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 14, 2018 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 16-24 | Shenandoah | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Hanover | W 65-14 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | North Central | L 52-59 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Washington and Lee | W 52-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Johns Hopkins | W 45-35 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Muhlenberg | W 35-29 (ot) | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2021 | North Central | L 13-26 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Salisbury | W 51-0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Utica | W 45-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Delaware Valley | W 22-6 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2022 | Wartburg | W 34-31 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2022 | North Central | L 21-28 | Annapolis | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Alfred State | W 56-14 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Alma | L 20-24 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | John Carroll | W 42-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Carnegie Mellon | W 24-19 | Alliance | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Salisbury | W 38-17 | Salisbury | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2024 | Johns Hopkins | W 45-37 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sun., Jan. 5, 2025 | North Central | L 25-41 | Houston | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Muhlenberg | W 49-7 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | John Carroll | L 7-10 (ot) | Alliance | Third Round |
Muhlenberg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Massachusetts-Dartmouth | W 56-6 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | John Carroll | L 10-21 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Christopher Newport | L 20-24 | Newport News | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | St. John Fisher | L 3-31 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Salisbury | W 31-21 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Wesley | L 21-38 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wesley | L 0-20 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Wesley | L 14-53 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Widener | L 35-36 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Delaware Valley | W 20-13 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Randolph-Macon | W 35-6 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Mount Union | L 10-38 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | MIT | W 38-0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Brockport | W 42-0 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Salisbury | W 24-8 | Salisbury | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2019 | North Central | L 14-45 | Allentown | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Framingham State | W 45-0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Delaware Valley | W 14-0 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Mount Union | L 29-35 (ot) | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Union | W 34-26 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Mount Union | L 7-49 | Alliance | Second Round |
College of New Jersey
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Ithaca | W 24-14 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Hofstra | L 3-38 | Ewing | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Coast Guard | W 17-16 | Ewing | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Rowan | L 3-7 | Ewing | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Cortland | W 34-30 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Rowan | L 7-13 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Rowan | L 2-26 | Ewing | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | RPI | W 17-14 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Mount Union | L 7-59 | Alliance | Second Round |
North Carolina Wesleyan
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Washington and Jefferson | W 35-34 (ot) | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 0-64 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Wesley | L 23-55 | Dover | First Round |
North Central
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Capital | L 19-21 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Concordia (WI) | W 35-6 | Milwaukee | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Capital | L 13-41 | Bexley | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Franklin | W 44-42 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 28-59 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Thomas More | W 44-23 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Franklin | L 28-38 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | St. Norbert | W 57-7 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Ohio Northern | W 28-9 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 10-20 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Dubuque | W 59-13 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Wabash | L 28-29 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | California Lutheran | W 41-21 | Thousand Oaks | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Linfield | L 14-30 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Albion | W 63-7 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Wisconsin-Platteville | W 52-24 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Bethel | W 41-17 | Arden Hills | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2013 | Mount Union | L 40-41 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Rose-Hulman | W 41-7 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Wheaton | L 14-31 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | St. John's | W 17-7 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 21-42 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Hanover | W 52-0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Bethel | L 24-27 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Wabash | W 51-15 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Mount Union | W 59-52 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Delaware Valley | W 31-14 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2019 | Muhlenberg | W 45-14 | Allentown | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 20, 2019 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 41-14 | Shenandoah | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 34-20 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | RPI | W 55-6 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2021 | Mount Union | W 26-13 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 17, 2021 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 24-57 | Canton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Lake Forest | W 50-0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Carnegie Mellon | W 28-7 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Ithaca | W 48-7 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2022 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 49-14 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2022 | Mount Union | W 28-21 | Annapolis | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Belhaven | W 65-0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Trinity (TX) | W 71-28 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 55-42 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2023 | Wartburg | W 34-27 | Waverly | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 15, 2023 | Cortland | L 37-38 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Whitworth | W 42-17 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Hope | W 41-21 | Naperville | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Springfield | W 27-3 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2024 | Susquehanna | W 66-0 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Sun., Jan. 5, 2025 | Mount Union | W 41-25 | Houston | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Hanover | W 38-6 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 35-27 | Naperville | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Bethel | W 35-21 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2025 | John Carroll | W 41-21 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Sun., Jan. 4, 2026 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 14-24 | Canton | Stagg Bowl |
Northwestern (MN)
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | St. Thomas | L 0-43 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | St. John's | L 0-49 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 14-59 | La Crosse | First Round |
Norwich
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Delaware Valley | L 10-62 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Albright | L 0-49 | Reading | First Round |
Occidental
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 42-43 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Central | L 22-23 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | St. John's | W 28-10 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Central | L 0-71 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Willamette | W 28-14 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 42-40 | Fargo | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Linfield | L 27-56 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Linfield | L 21-63 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Whitworth | L 23-27 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Willamette | L 33-48 | Salem | First Round |
Ohio Northern
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Hanover | W 56-14 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Wittenberg | W 58-24 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Mount Union | L 31-56 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Millikin | W 47-21 | Ada | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Mount Union | L 28-59 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Wittenberg | W 37-14 | Ada | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | North Central | L 9-28 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Franklin | W 27-22 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 7-42 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
Olivet
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Central | L 17-38 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | John Carroll | L 12-37 | Cleveland | First Round |
Otterbein
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Franklin | L 45-62 | Westerville | First Round |
Pacific Lutheran
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | St. John's | L 20-33 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Willamette | W 28-24 | Salem | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Wartburg | W 49-14 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | St. John's | W 19-9 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1999 | Trinity (TX) | W 49-28 | San Antonio | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 1999 | Rowan | W 42-13 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Bethel | W 41-13 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | St. John's | L 21-28 (ot) | Tacoma | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Whitworth | W 27-26 (ot) | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Central | W 27-21 (ot) | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | St. John's | L 6-31 | Fargo | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Linfield | L 24-27 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Linfield | L 21-42 | McMinnville | First Round |
Plymouth State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Union | L 14-26 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Merchant Marine | W 19-18 | Plymouth | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Ithaca | L 7-22 | Plymouth | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Union | L 7-24 | Plymouth | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Cortland | L 14-31 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Brockport | L 0-66 | Brockport | First Round |
Pomona-Pitzer
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Linfield | L 24-51 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Whitworth | L 13-21 | Spokane | First Round |
Randolph-Macon
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Washington and Jefferson | L 21-22 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Mount Union | L 0-56 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Johns Hopkins | L 21-42 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | John Carroll | W 23-20 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Muhlenberg | L 6-35 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Cortland | W 35-28 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Delaware Valley | L 32-39 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Christopher Newport | W 28-20 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Ithaca | W 46-0 | Ashland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Johns Hopkins | W 39-36 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2023 | Cortland | L 14-49 | Ashland | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Washington and Jefferson | W 38-22 | Ashland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Salisbury | L 14-35 | Salisbury | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | John Carroll | L 6-35 | Cleveland | Second Round |
Redlands
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Central | L 14-24 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 26-47 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | St. John's | L 24-31 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Linfield | L 23-31 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | St. John's | L 13-41 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 13-34 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-35 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 28-50 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 14-43 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Linfield | L 10-44 | McMinnville | First Round |
RPI
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Rowan | L 10-29 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Ithaca | L 10-27 | Troy | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Curry | W 34-20 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Springfield | W 40-34 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | Ithaca | W 21-16 | Troy | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2003 | St. John's | L 10-38 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | College of New Jersey | L 14-17 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Wesley | L 27-45 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Husson | W 38-14 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Brockport | W 21-13 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Johns Hopkins | L 14-37 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Endicott | W 20-14 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Cortland | W 21-14 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | North Central | L 6-55 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
Rhodes
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Ferrum | L 10-34 | Rocky Mount | Regional |
Rochester
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Wagner | L 14-38 | Staten Island | First Round |
Rose-Hulman
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | North Central | L 7-41 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | DePauw | L 21-26 | Greencastle | First Round |
Rowan
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Ithaca | L 10-31 | Ithaca | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | WPI | W 41-14 | Glassboro | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Buffalo State | W 28-19 | Buffalo | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1992 | Washington and Jefferson | L 13-18 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Buffalo State | W 29-6 | Glassboro | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | William Paterson | W 37-0 | Wayne | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1993 | Washington and Jefferson | W 23-16 | Washington | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1993 | Mount Union | L 24-34 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Buffalo State | W 46-7 | Buffalo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Union | W 38-7 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1995 | Washington and Jefferson | W 28-15 | Washington | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 1995 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 7-36 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Buffalo State | W 21-20 | Buffalo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | College of New Jersey | W 7-3 | Ewing | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1996 | Lycoming | W 33-14 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 1996 | Mount Union | L 24-56 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Coast Guard | W 43-0 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | College of New Jersey | W 13-7 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1997 | Lycoming | L 20-28 | Williamsport | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | College of New Jersey | W 26-2 | Ewing | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Buffalo State | W 19-17 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1998 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | W 22-19 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1998 | Mount Union | L 24-44 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | RPI | W 29-10 | Troy | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Ursinus | W 55-0 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Montclair State | W 42-13 | Upper Montclair | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1999 | Mount Union | W 24-17 (ot) | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | L 13-42 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Brockport | W 40-17 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Western Connecticut | W 43-14 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Ithaca | W 48-0 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2001 | Bridgewater | L 24-29 | Bridgewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Brockport | L 12-15 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Hobart | W 45-14 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Delaware Valley | W 56-7 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2004 | Linfield | L 0-52 | McMinnville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Wilkes | W 42-3 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Union | W 28-24 | Schenectady | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Delaware Valley | W 27-21 | Doylestown | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2005 | Mount Union | L 7-19 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Hobart | W 20-18 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wilkes | W 21-14 | Wilkes-Barre | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | St. John Fisher | L 0-31 | Pittsford | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Salisbury | L 9-17 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Endicott | W 24-0 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 8-59 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Johns Hopkins | L 16-24 | Baltimore | First Round |
St. John Fisher
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Muhlenberg | W 31-3 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Delaware Valley | L 20-26 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Union | W 49-21 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Springfield | W 27-21 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Rowan | W 31-0 | Pittsford | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2006 | Mount Union | L 14-26 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Hobart | W 24-7 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Curry | W 38-7 | Pittsford | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Mount Union | L 10-52 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Johns Hopkins | W 23-12 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Delaware Valley | W 27-14 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | St. Thomas | L 10-45 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | John Carroll | W 25-16 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Hobart | W 27-6 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 23-45 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
St. John's
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | Augustana | W 46-7 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1976 | Buena Vista | W 61-0 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1976 | Towson State | W 31-28 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Wabash | L 9-20 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Occidental | L 10-28 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Gustavus Adolphus | W 7-3 | St. Peter | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Central | L 3-13 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Simpson | W 42-35 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Central | W 27-24 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1989 | Dayton | L 0-28 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Coe | W 75-2 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 29-10 | Minneapolis | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1991 | Dayton | L 7-19 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Coe | W 32-14 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 47-25 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1993 | Mount Union | L 8-56 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | La Verne | W 51-12 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Wartburg | W 42-14 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1994 | Albion | L 16-19 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Simpson | W 21-18 | Minneapolis | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 30-37 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Pacific Lutheran | W 33-20 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | L 7-10 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | W 23-10 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Central | W 10-9 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | L 9-19 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Wisconsin-Stout | W 26-19 | Menomonie | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Pacific Lutheran | W 28-21 (ot) | Tacoma | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Central | W 21-18 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2000 | Hardin-Simmons | W 38-14 | Abilene | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 16, 2000 | Mount Union | L 7-10 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | St. Norbert | W 27-20 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | W 9-7 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Pacific Lutheran | W 31-6 | Fargo | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2001 | Mount Union | L 14-35 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Redlands | W 31-24 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Coe | W 45-14 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Linfield | W 21-14 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2002 | Trinity (TX) | L 34-41 | San Antonio | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | St. Norbert | W 38-13 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | Linfield | W 31-25 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2003 | RPI | W 38-10 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2003 | Mount Union | W 24-6 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Monmouth | W 62-3 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-34 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Central | W 21-13 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Whitworth | W 21-3 | Spokane | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-17 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Redlands | W 41-13 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Central | L 7-37 | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-37 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Coe | L 27-34 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | St. Scholastica | W 35-7 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wartburg | L 10-21 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Dubuque | W 51-7 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | St. Thomas | L 19-38 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wisconsin-Platteville | W 32-31 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 14-31 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | North Central | L 7-17 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Martin Luther | W 84-6 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Whitworth | W 45-24 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 18-21 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Aurora | W 51-47 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Chapman | W 55-26 | Orange | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Wheaton | W 34-33 | Wheaton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2019 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 32-35 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Lake Forest | W 41-14 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Linfield | L 28-31 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Northwestern (MN) | W 49-0 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Wartburg | L 20-23 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 24-13 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Susquehanna | L 38-41 | Collegeville | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Monmouth | W 49-15 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 14-42 | River Falls | Third Round |
St. Lawrence
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | Albright | W 26-7 | Canton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1976 | Towson State | L 36-38 | Towson | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Baldwin Wallace | L 7-71 | Berea | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Wagner | W 43-34 | Staten Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1982 | Augustana | L 0-14 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Mount Union | L 0-49 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Mount Union | L 23-55 | Alliance | First Round |
St. Norbert
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Central | L 7-55 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Augustana | L 32-39 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Central | L 14-29 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | St. John's | L 20-27 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Simpson | W 26-20 (ot) | De Pere | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | St. John's | L 13-38 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 23-37 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 17-59 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | L 20-24 | De Pere | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | North Central | L 7-57 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | St. Thomas | L 17-48 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-31 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 0-48 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Trine | W 31-7 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-54 | Whitewater | Second Round |
St. Olaf
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Minnesota-Morris | L 10-23 | Morris | First Round |
St. Scholastica
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | St. Thomas | L 2-48 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 10-55 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Bethel | L 13-70 | Minneapolis | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | St. John's | L 7-35 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 0-48 | Oshkosh | First Round |
St. Thomas
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 24-23 | Whitewater | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Central | L 32-33 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Monmouth | W 43-21 | Monmouth | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Coe | W 34-7 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Linfield | L 20-31 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Benedictine | W 57-10 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Linfield | W 24-17 (ot) | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Bethel | L 7-12 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | St. Scholastica | W 48-2 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Monmouth | W 38-10 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | St. John Fisher | W 45-10 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 0-20 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | St. Norbert | W 48-17 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Elmhurst | W 24-17 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Hobart | W 47-7 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2012 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | W 28-14 | St. Paul | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 14, 2012 | Mount Union | L 10-28 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wartburg | L 31-37 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | La Verne | W 57-14 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | St. John's | W 38-19 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Wabash | W 38-7 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2015 | Linfield | W 38-17 | St. Paul | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 18, 2015 | Mount Union | L 35-49 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Northwestern (MN) | W 43-0 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Coe | W 55-6 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 31-34 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Eureka | W 47-8 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Berry | W 29-13 | St. Paul | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 10-24 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
Salisbury
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Carnegie Mellon | W 16-14 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1983 | Union | L 21-23 | Salisbury | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Carnegie Mellon | W 35-22 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Gettysburg | L 6-22 | Gettysburg | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Emory and Henry | W 34-20 | Bristol | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Susquehanna | W 31-17 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1986 | Ithaca | W 44-40 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 1986 | Augustana | L 3-31 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | King's | L 0-28 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Christopher Newport | L 24-35 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Muhlenberg | L 21-31 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Delaware Valley | L 12-23 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Western New England | W 62-24 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Kean | W 49-47 (ot) | Salisbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-34 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Rowan | W 17-9 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Widener | L 7-28 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Cortland | L 21-45 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Maritime College | W 83-0 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Union | W 62-41 | Salisbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Muhlenberg | L 8-24 | Salisbury | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Johns Hopkins | L 20-45 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Mount Union | L 0-51 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | King's | W 33-13 | Salisbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Randolph-Macon | W 35-14 | Salisbury | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Mount Union | L 17-38 | Salisbury | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Endicott | W 35-28 | Salisbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Johns Hopkins | L 13-45 | Baltimore | Third Round |
San Diego
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1973 | Wittenberg | L 14-21 | Springfield | Semifinal |
Shenandoah
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Delaware Valley | L 17-21 | Doylestown | First Round |
Simpson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 27-29 | Indianola | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | St. John's | L 35-42 | Collegeville | Regional |
| Sun., Nov. 24, 1991 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 13-28 | Cedar Falls | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | St. John's | L 18-21 | Minneapolis | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 34-31 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Augsburg | W 61-21 | Indianola | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1997 | Mount Union | L 7-54 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | St. Norbert | L 20-26 (ot) | De Pere | First Round |
Slippery Rock
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1974 | Ithaca | L 14-27 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
Springfield
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Buffalo State | L 35-38 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Montclair State | W 31-29 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Brockport | W 13-6 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Widener | L 27-61 | Springfield | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Brockport | L 0-16 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | RPI | L 34-40 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Curry | W 42-14 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | St. John Fisher | L 21-27 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Husson | L 21-23 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Cortland | L 21-26 | Cortland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Endicott | W 17-14 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Ithaca | L 20-31 | Ithaca | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Ithaca | L 7-21 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Massachusetts-Dartmouth | W 54-27 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Cortland | W 40-28 | Cortland | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | North Central | L 3-27 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Cortland | W 21-7 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Johns Hopkins | L 14-34 | Baltimore | Second Round |
Stevenson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wesley | L 17-38 | Dover | First Round |
Susquehanna
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Washington and Jefferson | W 28-20 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1986 | Salisbury | L 17-31 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Dickinson | W 21-20 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Lycoming | W 31-24 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1991 | Ithaca | L 13-49 | Selinsgrove | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Delaware Valley | L 7-66 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Utica | L 10-17 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Grove City | L 20-21 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Hobart | W 42-35 | Selinsgrove | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | St. John's | W 41-38 | Collegeville | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2024 | Bethel | W 24-21 | Selinsgrove | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2024 | North Central | L 0-66 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Washington and Jefferson | W 38-32 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Christopher Newport | W 42-28 | Newport News | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Eastern | W 29-0 | St. Davids | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Johns Hopkins | L 10-40 | Baltimore | Quarterfinal |
Texas Lutheran
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 20-27 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Linfield | L 3-65 | McMinnville | Second Round |
Thiel
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Johns Hopkins | W 28-3 | Greenville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Bridgewater | L 13-24 | Greenville | Second Round |
Thomas More
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Emory and Henry | L 0-17 | Emory | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | MacMurray | W 34-30 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Wittenberg | L 0-41 | Crestview Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | North Central | L 23-44 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | DePauw | W 49-39 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Johns Hopkins | L 29-31 | Crestview Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Washington and Lee | W 42-14 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-69 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Franklin | L 21-24 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Washington and Lee | W 51-21 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Wabash | L 27-33 (ot) | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wittenberg | L 30-33 (ot) | Crestview Hills | First Round |
Towson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1976 | C.W. Post | W 14-10 | Brookville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1976 | St. Lawrence | W 38-36 | Towson | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1976 | St. John's | L 28-31 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
Trine
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wheaton | L 0-14 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Case Western Reserve | W 51-38 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Wittenberg | L 17-34 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | DePauw | W 45-35 | Greencastle | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 31-45 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Monmouth | W 63-24 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Wartburg | L 7-49 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | St. Norbert | L 7-31 | Angola | First Round |
Trinity (TX)
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Washington and Jefferson | L 0-28 | San Antonio | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Catholic | W 44-33 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1997 | Lycoming | L 26-46 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Western Maryland | W 30-20 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Lycoming | W 37-21 | Williamsport | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1998 | Mount Union | L 29-34 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Western Maryland | W 20-16 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1999 | Hardin-Simmons | W 40-33 | San Antonio | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | L 28-49 | San Antonio | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Wesley | W 21-3 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Bridgewater | W 47-41 (ot) | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Hardin-Simmons | L 30-33 | Abilene | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 30-6 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Bridgewater | L 37-41 | Bridgewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 48-38 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Washington and Jefferson | W 45-10 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Bridgewater | W 38-32 | Bridgewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2002 | St. John's | W 41-34 | San Antonio | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2002 | Mount Union | L 7-48 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | East Texas Baptist | L 41-42 (ot) | Marshall | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 13-32 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 6-35 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 23-52 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | McMurry | L 16-25 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 3-13 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Hardin-Simmons | W 14-7 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 17-24 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Hardin-Simmons | W 20-6 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | North Central | L 28-71 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 22-29 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Hardin-Simmons | W 34-24 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Berry | L 23-31 | Mount Berry | Third Round |
Union
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Hofstra | W 51-19 | Hempstead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1983 | Salisbury | W 23-21 | Salisbury | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1983 | Augustana | L 17-21 | Kings Mills | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Plymouth State | W 26-14 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1984 | Augustana | L 6-23 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Ithaca | L 12-13 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Ithaca | L 17-24 (ot) | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Cortland | W 42-14 | Schenectady | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1989 | Montclair State | W 45-6 | Schenectady | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1989 | Ferrum | W 37-21 | Rocky Mount | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 1989 | Dayton | L 7-17 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Massachusetts-Lowell | W 55-16 | Schenectady | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | Ithaca | L 23-35 | Ithaca | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | William Paterson | L 7-17 | Schenectady | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Plymouth State | W 24-7 | Plymouth | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Rowan | L 7-38 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Widener | L 26-33 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Ithaca | W 55-41 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Rowan | L 24-28 | Schenectady | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | St. John Fisher | L 21-49 | Pittsford | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Case Western Reserve | W 24-21 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Salisbury | L 41-62 | Salisbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Delaware Valley | W 24-16 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Johns Hopkins | L 17-39 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Muhlenberg | L 26-34 | Allentown | First Round |
Ursinus
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Lycoming | L 24-31 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Bridgewater State | W 43-38 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Rowan | L 0-55 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | King's | L 29-32 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
Utica
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Susquehanna | W 17-10 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | Mount Union | L 7-45 | Alliance | Second Round |
Wabash
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | St. John's | W 20-9 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1977 | Minnesota-Morris | W 37-21 | Crawfordsville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1977 | Widener | L 36-39 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | MacMurray | W 42-7 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Wittenberg | W 25-14 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2002 | Mount Union | L 16-45 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Albion | W 38-20 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Capital | L 11-14 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Mount St. Joseph | W 31-21 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Case Western Reserve | W 38-23 | Cleveland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-47 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Case Western Reserve | W 20-17 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Wheaton | L 28-59 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Illinois Wesleyan | L 35-41 (ot) | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Illinois College | W 38-20 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | North Central | W 29-28 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Mount Union | L 8-20 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Franklin | W 33-14 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 14-38 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Albion | W 35-14 | Crawfordsville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Thomas More | W 33-27 (ot) | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | St. Thomas | L 7-38 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | North Central | L 15-51 | Naperville | First Round |
Wagner
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Ithaca | L 13-41 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | St. Lawrence | L 34-43 | Staten Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Rochester | W 38-14 | Staten Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Fordham | W 21-0 | Bronx | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1987 | Emory and Henry | W 20-15 | Emory | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1987 | Dayton | W 19-3 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Ithaca | L 31-34 (ot) | Staten Island | Regional |
Wartburg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Bishop | L 7-32 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 26-55 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Central | W 22-21 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | St. John's | L 14-42 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | L 14-49 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Lake Forest | W 45-0 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Linfield | L 15-52 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Bethel | W 21-7 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Linfield | L 20-23 | Salem | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Concordia-Moorhead | L 14-28 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | W 26-21 | Stevens Point | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Monmouth | W 30-28 | Monmouth | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 17-34 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Bethel | L 20-28 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 41-7 | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Bethel | L 27-34 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | St. Thomas | W 37-31 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | St. John's | W 21-10 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 33-37 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Franklin | W 35-34 (ot) | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Trine | W 49-7 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 27-41 | Oshkosh | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Bethel | L 14-41 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Hope | W 41-3 | Holland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 28-41 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 14-6 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2022 | St. John's | W 23-20 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2022 | Aurora | W 45-17 | Waverly | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2022 | Mount Union | L 31-34 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Illinois College | W 49-14 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Whitworth | W 42-20 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | W 31-28 | Waverly | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2023 | North Central | L 27-34 | Waverly | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Wisconsin-Platteville | W 19-14 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2024 | Bethel | L 14-24 | Waverly | Third Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wheaton | L 24-28 | Waverly | Second Round |
Washington
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Hardin-Simmons | L 21-28 | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Franklin | L 10-17 | Franklin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L 13-49 | Oshkosh | First Round |
Washington and Jefferson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1984 | Randolph-Macon | W 22-21 | Ashland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1984 | Central | L 0-20 | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Susquehanna | L 20-28 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Allegheny | W 23-17 (ot) | Meadville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Emory and Henry | L 16-23 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Ferrum | L 7-41 | Rocky Mount | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | Ferrum | W 10-7 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Lycoming | L 0-24 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1991 | Lycoming | L 16-18 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Lycoming | W 33-0 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Emory and Henry | W 51-15 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1992 | Rowan | W 18-13 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 12-16 | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Moravian | W 27-7 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Frostburg State | W 28-7 | Frostburg | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1993 | Rowan | L 16-23 | Washington | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Trinity (TX) | W 28-0 | San Antonio | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Widener | W 37-21 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1994 | Ithaca | W 23-19 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 1994 | Albion | L 15-38 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Emory and Henry | W 35-16 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Lycoming | W 48-0 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1995 | Rowan | L 15-28 | Washington | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Albright | L 17-31 | Washington | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Lycoming | W 14-7 | Williamsport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Hardin-Simmons | L 3-51 | Abilene | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Bridgewater | L 42-59 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Western Maryland | W 24-21 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Widener | L 30-46 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Christopher Newport | W 24-10 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Trinity (TX) | L 10-45 | San Antonio | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Bridgewater | W 55-48 (ot) | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Christopher Newport | W 24-14 | Washington | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2004 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 16-52 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Bridgewater | L 21-30 | Bridgewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Christopher Newport | W 27-23 | Newport News | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 27-30 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | North Carolina Wesleyan | L 34-35 (ot) | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Christopher Newport | W 35-29 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Millsaps | W 35-20 | Jackson | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-63 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Mount Union | L 0-55 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Johns Hopkins | L 10-42 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Mount Union | L 20-34 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Wittenberg | W 41-25 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Mount Union | L 0-67 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Johns Hopkins | W 31-28 | Washington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Frostburg State | L 23-46 | Washington | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Centre | L 13-54 | Danville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Randolph-Macon | L 22-38 | Ashland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Susquehanna | L 32-38 | Selinsgrove | First Round |
Washington and Lee
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wilkes | L 0-42 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Thomas More | L 14-42 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Hobart | L 20-38 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Thomas More | L 21-51 | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Mount Union | L 0-21 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Mount Union | L 0-52 | Alliance | First Round |
Waynesburg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Bridgewater | L 24-28 | Bridgewater | First Round |
Wesley
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Trinity (TX) | L 3-21 | San Antonio | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Ferrum | W 59-14 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 46-36 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Bridgewater | W 46-7 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 6-58 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Dickinson | W 49-21 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Carnegie Mellon | W 37-0 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 34-20 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2006 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-44 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Hampden-Sydney | W 45-17 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Muhlenberg | W 38-21 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 10-27 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Muhlenberg | W 20-0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 14-46 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | North Carolina Wesleyan | W 55-23 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Mississippi College | W 43-9 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Johns Hopkins | W 12-0 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2009 | Mount Union | L 7-24 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Muhlenberg | W 53-14 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Montclair State | W 44-7 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 19-9 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2010 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 7-27 | Dover | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Hobart | W 35-28 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Linfield | W 49-34 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 27-24 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2011 | Mount Union | L 21-28 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Mount Ida | W 73-14 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Cortland | W 56-6 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 20-32 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Johns Hopkins | W 29-24 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Ithaca | W 23-15 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Mount Union | L 59-62 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Hampden-Sydney | W 52-7 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | MIT | W 59-0 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Hobart | W 41-13 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2014 | Mount Union | L 21-70 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Framingham State | W 42-22 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Johns Hopkins | W 42-37 | Baltimore | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Mount Union | L 35-56 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Stevenson | W 38-17 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | John Carroll | L 17-20 (ot) | Cleveland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | RPI | W 45-27 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | Brockport | L 28-49 | Brockport | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Framingham State | W 58-21 | Dover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Delaware Valley | L 10-45 | Dover | Second Round |
West Georgia
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | Widener | L 3-10 | Carrollton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | Widener | W 31-24 (ot) | Carrollton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1982 | Bishop | W 27-6 | Carrollton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1982 | Augustana | W 14-0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
Western Connecticut
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Montclair State | L 0-28 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Montclair State | L 24-32 | Danbury | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Westfield State | W 8-7 | Westfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Rowan | L 14-43 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Johns Hopkins | L 20-62 | Baltimore | First Round |
Western New England
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Salisbury | L 24-62 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Johns Hopkins | L 20-52 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Husson | W 44-27 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Alfred | L 24-30 | Alfred | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Delaware Valley | L 0-35 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Frostburg State | L 24-42 | Frostburg | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Brockport | L 28-33 | Springfield | First Round |
Westfield State
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Western Connecticut | L 7-8 | Westfield | First Round |
Wheaton
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Wittenberg | W 63-41 | Wheaton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Mount Union | L 14-40 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Alma | W 42-14 | Alma | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Mount Union | L 21-42 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Hope | W 55-45 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Baldwin Wallace | W 16-12 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2003 | Mount Union | L 10-56 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Mount St. Joseph | W 31-7 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Mount Union | L 6-27 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Mount St. Joseph | W 42-28 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Mount Union | L 3-35 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Trine | W 14-0 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Wabash | W 59-28 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Franklin | W 45-28 | Franklin | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2008 | Mount Union | L 24-45 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Coe | W 31-21 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Bethel | L 10-15 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Benedictine | W 43-14 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | John Carroll | L 12-14 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Lakeland | W 55-6 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 17-31 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Huntingdon | W 45-10 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | North Central | W 31-14 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 16-38 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Martin Luther | W 51-7 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Central | W 49-13 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | St. John's | L 33-34 | Wheaton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Aurora | W 63-31 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Central | L 28-30 | Pella | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Bethel | L 32-34 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Mount St. Joseph | W 41-34 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 42-49 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Crown | W 76-14 | Wheaton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Wartburg | W 28-24 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | DePauw | W 49-24 | Greencastle | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Wisconsin-River Falls | L 21-46 | River Falls | Quarterfinal |
Whitworth
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Pacific Lutheran | L 26-27 (ot) | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Occidental | W 27-23 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | St. John's | L 3-21 | Spokane | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Linfield | L 10-48 | McMinnville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | W 48-6 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | St. John's | L 24-45 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Chapman | W 42-28 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Wartburg | L 20-42 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Pomona-Pitzer | W 21-13 | Spokane | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | North Central | L 17-42 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2025 | Chapman | L 16-18 | Spokane | First Round |
Widener
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1975 | Albright | W 14-6 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1975 | Ithaca | L 14-23 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Central | W 19-0 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1977 | Albany | W 33-15 | Chester | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 1977 | Wabash | W 39-36 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Baldwin Wallace | W 29-8 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1979 | Wittenberg | L 14-17 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Bethany | W 43-12 | Bethany | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1980 | Dayton | L 24-28 | Chester | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1981 | West Georgia | W 10-3 | Carrollton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1981 | Montclair State | W 23-12 | Chester | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1981 | Dayton | W 17-10 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1982 | West Georgia | L 24-31 (ot) | Carrollton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Moravian | L 7-17 | Bethlehem | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Dickinson | W 14-0 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1994 | Washington and Jefferson | L 21-37 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Lycoming | L 27-31 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Union | W 33-26 | Schenectady | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Hobart | W 40-14 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Springfield | W 61-27 | Springfield | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2000 | Mount Union | L 30-70 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Christopher Newport | W 56-7 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Washington and Jefferson | W 46-30 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Bridgewater | L 32-57 | Bridgewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Case Western Reserve | L 20-21 | Cleveland | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Bridgewater State | W 44-14 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Salisbury | W 28-7 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Mount Union | L 17-72 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Muhlenberg | W 36-35 | Chester | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Christopher Newport | W 37-27 | Chester | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Linfield | L 7-45 | Chester | Quarterfinal |
Wilkes
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Frostburg State | L 25-26 | Wilkes-Barre | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Rowan | L 3-42 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Washington and Lee | W 42-0 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Rowan | L 14-21 | Wilkes-Barre | Second Round |
Willamette
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | L 24-28 | Salem | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Occidental | L 14-28 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Occidental | W 48-33 | Salem | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 27-30 | Salem | Second Round |
William Paterson
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Union | W 17-7 | Schenectady | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Rowan | L 0-37 | Wayne | Quarterfinal |
Wisconsin-Eau Claire
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Central | W 28-21 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | St. John's | W 10-7 | Collegeville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1998 | Rowan | L 19-22 | Glassboro | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | St. Norbert | W 24-20 | De Pere | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Bethel | L 12-21 | Arden Hills | Second Round |
Wisconsin-La Crosse
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1983 | Occidental | W 43-42 | Los Angeles | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1983 | Augustana | L 15-21 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sun., Nov. 24, 1991 | Simpson | W 28-13 | Cedar Falls | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1991 | St. John's | L 10-29 | Minneapolis | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Redlands | W 47-26 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1992 | Central | W 34-9 | Ames | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1992 | Mount Union | W 29-24 | La Crosse | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1992 | Washington and Jefferson | W 16-12 | Bradenton | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1993 | Wartburg | W 55-26 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | St. John's | L 25-47 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Concordia-Moorhead | W 45-7 | Fargo | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Wisconsin-River Falls | W 28-14 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1995 | Mount Union | W 20-17 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 1995 | Rowan | W 36-7 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Wisconsin-River Falls | W 44-0 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1996 | St. John's | W 37-30 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1996 | Mount Union | L 21-39 | Madison | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Central | L 17-38 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Coe | L 18-21 | Cedar Rapids | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2003 | Concordia (WI) | W 52-13 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2003 | Mount Union | L 14-39 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | St. Norbert | W 37-23 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Linfield | L 14-52 | McMinnville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Bethel | W 28-21 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 21-24 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Albion | W 58-23 | Albion | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | North Central | L 20-34 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Wartburg | L 6-14 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Minnesota-Morris | W 62-7 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Aurora | W 56-35 | La Crosse | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | North Central | L 42-55 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Northwestern (MN) | W 59-14 | La Crosse | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | St. John's | L 13-24 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Hope | W 9-7 | Holland | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | North Central | L 27-35 | Naperville | Third Round |
Wisconsin-Oshkosh
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | St. Scholastica | W 55-10 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Bethel | W 37-14 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2012 | Linfield | W 31-24 (ot) | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2012 | St. Thomas | L 14-28 | St. Paul | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | St. Scholastica | W 48-0 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Ohio Northern | W 42-7 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 29-31 | Oshkosh | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Washington | W 49-13 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | St. John's | W 31-14 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | St. Thomas | W 34-31 | St. Paul | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2016 | John Carroll | W 10-3 | Oshkosh | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2016 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-10 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Lakeland | W 63-0 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | North Central | W 42-21 | Oshkosh | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2017 | Wartburg | W 41-27 | Oshkosh | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2017 | Mount Union | L 40-43 | Oshkosh | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Central | L 37-38 (ot) | Pella | First Round |
Wisconsin-Platteville
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Concordia (WI) | W 54-20 | Platteville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | North Central | L 24-52 | Naperville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | St. John's | L 31-32 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2024 | Wartburg | L 14-19 | Waverly | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Alma | W 24-7 | Platteville | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Bethel | L 24-35 | Arden Hills | Third Round |
Wisconsin-River Falls
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Central | W 10-7 | Pella | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 14-28 | La Crosse | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | L 0-44 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | Chapman | W 58-7 | River Falls | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | St. John's | W 42-14 | River Falls | Third Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2025 | Wheaton | W 46-21 | River Falls | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2025 | Johns Hopkins | W 48-41 | River Falls | Semifinal |
| Sun., Jan. 4, 2026 | North Central | W 24-14 | Canton | Stagg Bowl |
Wisconsin-Stevens Point
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Concordia-Moorhead | L 15-24 | Moorhead | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | St. John's | L 10-23 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Bethel | W 37-27 | Stevens Point | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | St. John's | L 7-9 | Collegeville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wartburg | L 21-26 | Stevens Point | First Round |
Wisconsin-Stout
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | St. John's | L 19-26 | Menomonie | First Round |
Wisconsin-Whitewater
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Simpson | W 29-27 | Indianola | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Central | L 13-16 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1990 | St. Thomas | L 23-24 | Whitewater | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Simpson | L 31-34 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2005 | Central | W 34-14 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2005 | St. John's | W 34-7 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2005 | Linfield | W 44-41 | McMinnville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2005 | Wesley | W 58-6 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 17, 2005 | Mount Union | L 28-35 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | St. Norbert | W 59-17 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | W 24-21 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | St. John's | W 17-14 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2006 | Wesley | W 44-7 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 16, 2006 | Mount Union | L 16-35 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Capital | W 34-14 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | North Central | W 59-28 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2007 | Wabash | W 47-7 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2007 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 16-7 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 15, 2007 | Mount Union | W 31-21 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | St. John's | W 37-7 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Willamette | W 30-27 | Salem | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2008 | Wartburg | W 34-17 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2008 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 39-13 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 20, 2008 | Mount Union | L 26-31 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Lakeland | W 70-7 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Illinois Wesleyan | W 45-7 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Wittenberg | W 31-13 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2009 | Linfield | W 27-17 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 19, 2009 | Mount Union | W 38-28 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Franklin | W 52-21 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2010 | Trine | W 45-31 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2010 | North Central | W 20-10 | Naperville | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2010 | Wesley | W 27-7 | Dover | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 18, 2010 | Mount Union | W 31-21 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Albion | W 59-0 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2011 | Franklin | W 41-14 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2011 | Salisbury | W 34-14 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2011 | St. Thomas | W 20-0 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 16, 2011 | Mount Union | W 13-10 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | St. Norbert | W 31-7 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Franklin | W 33-3 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2013 | Linfield | W 28-17 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2013 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 16-15 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 20, 2013 | Mount Union | W 52-14 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Macalester | W 55-2 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wabash | W 38-14 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2014 | Wartburg | W 37-33 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2014 | Linfield | W 20-14 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 19, 2014 | Mount Union | W 43-34 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | St. Norbert | W 48-0 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2015 | Wheaton | W 31-17 | Wheaton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2015 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | W 31-29 | Oshkosh | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 2015 | Mount Union | L 6-36 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Lakeland | W 45-27 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Wittenberg | W 37-9 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 3, 2016 | John Carroll | L 14-31 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Eureka | W 67-14 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2018 | St. Norbert | W 54-21 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2018 | Bethel | W 26-12 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 2018 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 14-31 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Monmouth | W 35-10 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Wartburg | W 41-28 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 2019 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | W 26-7 | Belton | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 14, 2019 | St. John's | W 35-32 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 20, 2019 | North Central | L 14-41 | Shenandoah | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Greenville | W 69-7 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | DePauw | W 45-0 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 2021 | Central | W 51-21 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2021 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | L 7-24 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Aurora | L 28-33 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | Bethel | W 42-14 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Wheaton | W 49-42 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2023 | Wartburg | L 28-31 | Waverly | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2025 | DePauw | L 23-26 | Whitewater | Second Round |
Wittenberg
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1973 | San Diego | W 21-14 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1973 | Juniata | W 41-0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1975 | Millsaps | W 55-22 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1975 | Ithaca | W 28-0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1978 | Ithaca | W 6-3 | Ithaca | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1978 | Minnesota-Morris | W 35-14 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1978 | Baldwin Wallace | L 10-24 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 1979 | Millersville | W 21-14 | Millersville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1979 | Widener | W 17-14 | Springfield | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 1979 | Ithaca | L 10-14 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Dayton | W 35-28 (ot) | Dayton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 1988 | Augustana | L 14-28 | Springfield | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1995 | Wheaton | L 41-63 | Wheaton | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1998 | Millikin | W 13-10 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1998 | Mount Union | L 19-21 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 1999 | Alma | W 42-19 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Ohio Northern | L 24-58 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Aurora | W 31-20 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2000 | Hanover | W 32-21 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2000 | Mount Union | L 15-32 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2001 | Hardin-Simmons | W 38-35 (ot) | Abilene | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Thomas More | W 41-0 | Crestview Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Mount Union | L 21-49 | Alliance | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Hanover | W 34-33 | Hanover | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2002 | Wabash | L 14-25 | Crawfordsville | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Capital | L 14-32 | Bexley | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Mount St. Joseph | W 42-14 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 2009 | Trine | W 34-17 | Springfield | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 13-31 | Whitewater | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Ohio Northern | L 14-37 | Ada | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2012 | Heidelberg | W 52-38 | Tiffin | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2012 | Hobart | L 10-35 | Geneva | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Lebanon Valley | W 59-17 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2013 | Mount Union | L 21-56 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2014 | Washington and Jefferson | L 25-41 | Springfield | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | Thomas More | W 33-30 (ot) | Crestview Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 26, 2016 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | L 9-37 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Frostburg State | L 7-35 | Springfield | First Round |
Wooster
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2004 | Aurora | W 41-34 | Wooster | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2004 | Carthage | L 7-14 | Wooster | Second Round |
WPI
| DATE | OPPONENT | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Rowan | L 14-41 | Glassboro | Regional |