NOTE:
- A hash (#) indicates participation later vacated due to NCAA infractions.
Games
| DATE | RESULT | LOCATION | ROUND |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat., Dec. 8, 1973 | Wittenberg 41, Juniata 0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1975 | Wittenberg 28, Ithaca 0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1976 | St. John's 61, Buena Vista 0 | Collegeville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1977 | Widener 19, Central 0 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1980 | Dayton 34, Baldwin Wallace 0 | Dayton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 1980 | Ithaca 36, Minnesota-Morris 0 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 1980 | Dayton 63, Ithaca 0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1981 | Dayton 38, Lawrence 0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1982 | Augustana 14, St. Lawrence 0 | Rock Island | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 4, 1982 | West Georgia 14, Augustana 0 | Phenix City | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1984 | Central 20, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Pella | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1985 | Montclair State 28, Western Connecticut 0 | Upper Montclair | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 1985 | Central 71, Occidental 0 | Pella | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 7, 1985 | Ithaca 34, Gettysburg 0 | Ithaca | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1986 | Central 37, Buena Vista 0 | Storm Lake | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Central 17, Menlo 0 | Pella | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1987 | Augustana 53, Hiram 0 | Rock Island | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 28, 1987 | Wagner 21, Fordham 0 | Bronx | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 1987 | Dayton 34, Central 0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1988 | Central 7, Concordia-Moorhead 0 | Moorhead | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 1989 | Lycoming 21, Dickinson 0 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 1989 | Dayton 28, St. John's 0 | Dayton | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 1990 | Lycoming 24, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Emory and Henry 17, Thomas More 0 | Emory | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 1992 | Washington and Jefferson 33, Lycoming 0 | Williamsport | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1993 | Rowan 37, William Paterson 0 | Wayne | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Widener 14, Dickinson 0 | Carlisle | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 1994 | Washington and Jefferson 28, Trinity (TX) 0 | San Antonio | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 1995 | Washington and Jefferson 48, Lycoming 0 | Washington | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 1996 | Wisconsin-La Crosse 44, Wisconsin-River Falls 0 | La Crosse | Regional |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 1997 | Rowan 43, Coast Guard 0 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 1999 | Rowan 55, Ursinus 0 | Glassboro | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2000 | Hobart 25, Bridgewater State 0 | Geneva | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2001 | Wittenberg 41, Thomas More 0 | Crestview Hills | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 1, 2001 | Rowan 48, Ithaca 0 | Glassboro | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | King's 28, Salisbury 0 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Brockport 16, Springfield 0 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2002 | Wartburg 45, Lake Forest 0 | Waverly | First Round |
| Sat., Dec. 13, 2003 | Mount Union 66, Bridgewater 0 | Alliance | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 11, 2004 | Linfield 52, Rowan 0 | McMinnville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Carnegie Mellon 21, Millsaps 0 | Pittsburgh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Mount Union 49, Hope 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2006 | Wilkes 42, Washington and Lee 0 | Wilkes-Barre | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2006 | Wesley 37, Carnegie Mellon 0 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 2, 2006 | St. John Fisher 31, Rowan 0 | Pittsford | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2007 | Bethel 28, Concordia (WI) 0 | Arden Hills | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 24, 2007 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 64, North Carolina Wesleyan 0 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wesley 20, Muhlenberg 0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Mount Union 56, Randolph-Macon 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 22, 2008 | Wheaton 14, Trine 0 | Angola | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2008 | Cortland 42, Curry 0 | Cortland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2009 | Mount Union 55, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Dec. 5, 2009 | Wesley 12, Johns Hopkins 0 | Dover | Quarterfinal |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Mount Union 49, St. Lawrence 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2010 | Alfred 60, Maritime College 0 | Alfred | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 59, Albion 0 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Dec. 10, 2011 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 20, St. Thomas 0 | Whitewater | Semifinal |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2013 | Rowan 24, Endicott 0 | Glassboro | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Mount Union 67, Washington and Jefferson 0 | Alliance | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 29, 2014 | Wesley 59, MIT 0 | Dover | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Albright 49, Norwich 0 | Reading | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 48, St. Norbert 0 | Whitewater | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 21, 2015 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 48, St. Scholastica 0 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2016 | St. Thomas 43, Northwestern (MN) 0 | St. Paul | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Brockport 66, Plymouth State 0 | Brockport | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Case Western Reserve 28, Illinois Wesleyan 0 | Bloomington | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh 63, Lakeland 0 | Oshkosh | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Mount Union 21, Washington and Lee 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2017 | Delaware Valley 35, Western New England 0 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2017 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Linfield 0 | Belton | Second Round |
| Sat., Dec. 9, 2017 | #Mary Hardin-Baylor 24, Brockport 0 | Belton | Semifinal |
| Fri., Dec. 15, 2017 | Mount Union 12, #Mary Hardin-Baylor 0 | Salem | Stagg Bowl |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Mount Union 60, Denison 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Berry 31, Maryville 0 | Mount Berry | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | Johns Hopkins 49, MIT 0 | Baltimore | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 17, 2018 | North Central 52, Hanover 0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Salisbury 83, Maritime College 0 | Salisbury | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2019 | Muhlenberg 38, MIT 0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 30, 2019 | Muhlenberg 42, Brockport 0 | Allentown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Mount Union 52, Washington and Lee 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 20, 2021 | Muhlenberg 45, Framingham State 0 | Allentown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Muhlenberg 14, Delaware Valley 0 | Doylestown | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 27, 2021 | Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, DePauw 0 | Whitewater | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | North Central 50, Lake Forest 0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Mount Union 51, Salisbury 0 | Alliance | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 54, Huntingdon 0 | Belton | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | St. John's 49, Northwestern (MN) 0 | Collegeville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 19, 2022 | Delaware Valley 59, Gallaudet 0 | Doylestown | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 18, 2023 | North Central 65, Belhaven 0 | Naperville | First Round |
| Sat., Nov. 25, 2023 | Randolph-Macon 46, Ithaca 0 | Ashland | Second Round |
| Sat., Nov. 23, 2024 | Endicott 44, Alfred State 0 | Beverly | First Round |
| Sat., Dec. 21, 2024 | North Central 66, Susquehanna 0 | Naperville | Semifinal |
| Sat., Dec. 6, 2025 | Susquehanna 29, Eastern 0 | St. Davids | Third Round |